Abstract:Leadership in agile teams is a collective responsibility where team members share leadership work based on expertise and skills. However, the understanding of leadership in this context is limited. This study explores the under-researched area of prototypical leadership, aiming to understand if and how leaders who are perceived as more representative of the team are more effective leaders. Qualitative interviews were conducted with eleven members of six agile software teams in five Swedish companies from various industries and sizes. In this study, the effectiveness of leadership was perceived as higher when it emerged from within the team or when leaders aligned with the group. In addition, leaders in managerial roles that align with the team's shared values and traits were perceived as more effective, contributing to overall team success.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the leadership issue in agile software development teams, especially the role and influence of prototypical leadership. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following aspects:
1. **Understanding the concept of prototypical leadership and its manifestation in agile teams**: The paper explores whether leaders who are considered to be more representative of the team are more effective and how this leadership style affects the team's success.
2. **Members' perception and experience of leadership consistent with team characteristics and values**: Through qualitative interviews, the researchers attempt to understand how team members view and experience leadership behaviors (i.e., prototypical leadership) that are consistent with team characteristics and values.
3. **The impact of prototypical leadership on agile teams**: The research also evaluates the specific impact of prototypical leadership on team performance, collaboration, decision - making processes, and member satisfaction.
### Research Background
Agile software development emphasizes collaboration, flexibility, iterative development, and customer satisfaction. In this context, leadership is no longer limited to a single individual but is dynamically shared by team members based on their expertise and skills. However, research on this distributed leadership is relatively limited, especially in terms of prototypical leadership. Therefore, this research fills this research gap and aims to better understand the role of prototypical leadership in agile teams.
### Research Methods
To answer these questions, the researchers conducted qualitative interviews and collected data from 11 members of six agile software development teams in five companies in different industries and sizes in Sweden. Through thematic analysis of these data, the researchers identified three main themes:
1. **Shared leadership based on tasks and expertise**: Team members assume informal leadership roles according to their respective tasks and professional fields.
2. **Informal hierarchy based on seniority**: Senior members usually have greater influence in the team. They not only provide technical expertise but also share rich experience.
3. **The alignment between leaders and the team for success**: Whether leaders are appointed internally or externally, their effectiveness depends on whether they are aligned with the team's values and working methods.
### Main Findings
- **Shared leadership makes leadership behavior more representative**: Since leadership responsibilities are shared among team members, leadership behavior is regarded as more in line with the overall characteristics of the team.
- **Senior members assume more leadership responsibilities**: Senior members play an important role in leadership work because of their rich experience and understanding of the team.
- **Effective management leadership needs to be aligned with team goals and values**: Leaders should not only possess technical capabilities but also be aligned with the team's goals and values, actively participate in team activities, and enhance trust and collaboration.
### Conclusion
Prototypical leadership has a positive impact in agile teams, which can promote team collaboration, improve member satisfaction, and help reduce the turnover rate. The research results show that successful leadership is not only a manifestation of technical capabilities but also the result of alignment with the team and active participation. This provides valuable insights for organizations on how to cultivate efficient leadership.
---
Through this research, the author hopes to provide theoretical support for leadership practices in agile software development teams and provide directions for future research.