How (Not) to Incentivize Sustainable Mobility? Lessons from a Swiss Mobility Competition

Silvio Sticher,Hannes Wallimann,Noah Balthasar
2024-09-17
Abstract:We investigate the impact of a gamified experiment designed to promote sustainable mobility among students and staff members of a Swiss higher-education institution. Despite transportation being a major contributor to domestic CO2 emissions, achieving behavioral change remains challenging. In our two-month mobility competition, structured as a randomized controlled trial with a 3x3 factorial design, neither monetary incentives nor norm-based nudging significantly influences mobility behavior. Our (null) results suggest that there is no "gamified quick fix" for making mobility substantially more sustainable. Also, we provide some lessons learned on how not to incentivize sustainable mobility by addressing potential shortcomings of our mobility competition.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to promote sustainable travel behaviors among students and faculty in Swiss higher education institutions through gamified experiments (i.e., "mobility competitions"). Although transportation is one of the main factors contributing to domestic carbon dioxide emissions, achieving behavioral change remains challenging. The author designed a two - month - long mobility competition, using the randomized controlled trial (RCT) method combined with a 3×3 factorial design to explore the effects of financial incentives and norm - based guidance on mobility behaviors. The research results show that neither financial incentives nor normative guidance significantly affected the participants' mobility behaviors, indicating that it may not be easy to quickly achieve the sustainability of mobility behaviors through gamification means in the short term. The paper also provides some lessons on how not to encourage sustainable mobility and points out the potential deficiencies in the mobility competition.