Abstract:We theoretically investigate the temperature dependence of nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate $T_1^{-1}$ in bulk odd-frequency superconductivity. For a model odd-frequency pairing interaction, we first evaluate the superconducting order parameter, within the framework of the combined path-integral formalism with the saddle-point approximation. We then calculate $T_1^{-1}$ below the superconducting phase transition temperature $T_{\rm c}$, to see how the odd-frequency pairing affects this physical quantity. In the odd-frequency $p$-wave state, while the so-called coherence peak is suppressed as in the even-frequency $p$-wave case, $T_1^{-1}$ is found to exhibit the Korringa-law-like behavior ($T_1^{-1}\propto T$) except just below $T_{\rm c}$, even without impurity scatterings. In the odd-frequency $s$-wave case, the behavior of $T_{1}^{-1}$ is found to be sensitive to the detailed spin structure of the superconducting order parameter: In a case, $T_1^{-1}$ is enhanced far below $T_{\rm c}$, being in contrast to the conventional (even-frequency) $s$-wave BCS case, where the coherence peak appears just below $T_{\rm c}$. We also show that the calculated $T_1^{-1}$ in the odd-frequency $p$-wave case well explains the recent experiment on CeRh$_{0.5}$Ir$_{0.5}$In$_5$, where the possibility of odd-frequency $p$-wave superconductivity was recently suggested experimentally.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the temperature dependence of the nuclear spin - lattice relaxation rate \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency superconducting state. Specifically, the authors theoretically studied the behavioral characteristics of \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency superconducting state, especially in the odd - frequency p - wave and s - wave superconducting states, and explored how these characteristics are consistent with experimental observations.
### Main problems
1. **Behavior of \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state**:
- The paper studied whether \(T_1^{-1}\) would exhibit the behavior of Korringa's law, i.e., \(T_1^{-1}\propto T\), in the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state.
- The authors found that in the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state, although the coherence peak was suppressed, in the absence of impurity scattering, \(T_1^{-1}\) still exhibited the behavior of Korringa's law, which was consistent with the phenomenon observed in CeRh\(_{0.5}\)Ir\(_{0.5}\)In\(_5\) in experiments.
2. **Behavior of \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency s - wave superconducting state**:
- The paper also studied how the behavior of \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency s - wave superconducting state was affected by the spin structure of the superconducting order parameter.
- It was found that in some cases, \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency s - wave superconducting state would be enhanced far below \(T_c\), which was different from the coherence peak near \(T_c\) in the traditional even - frequency s - wave BCS state.
### Research background
- The odd - frequency superconducting state is an unconventional pairing state, which has been widely discussed in strongly correlated electron systems such as heavy fermion compounds, organic conductors, and transition - metal oxides in recent years.
- Recently, Kawasaki and his colleagues observed abnormal behavior of the nuclear spin - lattice relaxation rate \(T_1^{-1}\) near the quantum critical point in the heavy fermion superconductor CeRh\(_{0.5}\)Ir\(_{0.5}\)In\(_5\), suggesting the possible existence of an odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state.
### Research methods
- The authors used a theoretical method combining path - integral formalism and saddle - point approximation to calculate the superconducting order parameter and \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency superconducting state.
- By selecting an appropriate odd - frequency pairing interaction model, the density of states (SDOS) of the superconducting state was ensured to be positive in the low - energy region, thus avoiding unphysical results.
### Main conclusions
- In the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state, \(T_1^{-1}\) exhibited the behavior of Korringa's law, which was consistent with the experimental observation results and supported the possibility of the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state.
- In the odd - frequency s - wave superconducting state, the behavior of \(T_1^{-1}\) was very sensitive to the spin structure of the superconducting order parameter and would be significantly enhanced in some cases far below \(T_c\).
### Future research directions
- Further research is needed to confirm whether the odd - frequency p - wave superconducting state is superior to the non - magnetic impurity mechanism.
- Explore other odd - frequency pairing models to verify the universality of the results.
- Consider more realistic material details, such as the specific situation of CeRh\(_{0.5}\)Ir\(_{0.5}\)In\(_5\), to further verify the theoretical predictions.
In conclusion, through detailed theoretical calculations, this paper revealed the unique behavior of \(T_1^{-1}\) in the odd - frequency superconducting state, providing an important theoretical basis for understanding unconventional superconducting states.