Bootstrapping the Quantum Hall problem

Qiang Gao,Ryan A. Lanzetta,Patrick Ledwith,Jie Wang,Eslam Khalaf

2024-09-17

Abstract:The bootstrap method aims to solve problems by imposing constraints on the space of physical observables, which often follow from physical assumptions such as positivity and symmetry. Here, we employ a bootstrap approach to study interacting electrons in the lowest Landau level by minimizing the energy as a function of the static structure factor subject to a set of constraints, bypassing the need to construct the full many-body wavefunction. This approach rigorously lower bounds the ground state energy, making it complementary to conventional variational upper bounds. We show that the lower bound we obtain is relatively tight, within at most 5\% from the ground state energy computed with exact diagonalization (ED) at small system sizes, and generally gets tighter as we include more constraints. In addition to energetics, our results reproduce the correct power law dependence of the pair correlation function at short distances and the existence of a large entanglement gap in the two-particle entanglement spectra for the Laughlin states at $\nu = 1/3$. We further identify signatures of the composite Fermi liquid state close to half-filling. This shows that the bootstrap approach is capable, in principle, of describing non-trivial gapped topologically ordered, as well as gapless, phases. At the end, we will discuss possible extensions and limitations of this approach. Our work establishes numerical bootstrap as a promising method to study many-body phases in topological bands, paving the way to its application in moiré platforms where the energetic competition between fractional quantum anomalous Hall, symmetry broken, and gapless states remains poorly understood.

Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the quantum Hall problem of interacting electron systems in the lowest Landau level (LLL). Specifically, the author adopts a bootstrap approach, minimizing the energy by imposing a set of constraints on the static structure factor, thereby bypassing the need to construct a complete many - body wave function. This method can strictly give a lower bound on the ground - state energy, which is complementary to the upper bounds provided by traditional variational methods (such as the Hartree - Fock method and the density matrix renormalization group method). The paper shows that this method can reproduce the energy and correlation functions of known states with high precision and can identify the characteristics of the composite Fermi liquid state near half - filling. In addition, this method can also in principle describe non - trivial topologically ordered phases and gapless phases. Finally, the author discusses the possible extensions and limitations of this method and believes that the numerical bootstrap method has broad application prospects in studying many - body phases in topological bands, especially in the Moore platform, where the energy competition between different phases has not been fully understood.

### Main contributions of the paper

1. **Proposing a new numerical method**: The paper proposes a new method of using the bootstrap approach to study the quantum Hall problem. By imposing constraints on the static structure factor to minimize the energy, a strict lower bound on the ground - state energy is obtained.
2. **Reproducing known results with high precision**: This method can reproduce the ground - state energy calculated by the exact diagonalization method with an error of no more than 5% for small system sizes, and can accurately reproduce the power - law dependence of the pair - correlation function at short distances and the large entanglement gap in the two - particle entanglement spectrum of the Laughlin state.
3. **Identifying new physical phenomena**: The paper also identifies the characteristics of the composite Fermi liquid state near half - filling, indicating that the bootstrap method is capable of describing complex topologically ordered phases and gapless phases.
4. **Wide applicability of the method**: The author discusses the potential applications of this method in other systems, especially in the Moore platform, where the energy competition between different phases has not been fully understood.

### Mathematical and physical background

- **Static structure factor**: The static structure factor \(S_q\) is defined as \(S_q=\langle\rho_q\rho_{-q}\rangle\), where \(\rho_q\) is the guiding - center density operator. It contains all the information of the two - body correlation function in the system.
- **Energy expression**: For density - density interactions, the energy of the system can be completely determined by the static structure factor:
\[
E[S_q]=\frac{1}{2}\int\frac{d^2q}{2\pi}V_qe^{-\frac{q^2}{2}}S_q
\]
- **Haldane duality**: The static structure factor \(S_q\) satisfies Haldane duality:
\[
S_{p - N}=\pm\int\frac{d^2q}{2\pi}e^{iq\wedge p}(S_q - N)
\]
where the \(\pm\) signs correspond to bosons and fermions respectively, and the wedge product is defined as \(q\wedge p = q_xp_y - q_yp_x\).

### Conclusion

By introducing the bootstrap method, the paper provides a new numerical tool to study the quantum Hall problem, especially the interacting electron systems in the lowest Landau level. This method can not only strictly give a lower bound on the ground - state energy, but also reproduce the physical properties of known states with high precision and identify new physical phenomena. This method has important application prospects in studying many - body phases in topological bands.