Evaluating authenticity and quality of image captions via sentiment and semantic analyses

Aleksei Krotov,Alison Tebo,Dylan K. Picart,Aaron Dean Algave
2024-09-15
Abstract:The growth of deep learning (DL) relies heavily on huge amounts of labelled data for tasks such as natural language processing and computer vision. Specifically, in image-to-text or image-to-image pipelines, opinion (sentiment) may be inadvertently learned by a model from human-generated image captions. Additionally, learning may be affected by the variety and diversity of the provided captions. While labelling large datasets has largely relied on crowd-sourcing or data-worker pools, evaluating the quality of such training data is crucial. This study proposes an evaluation method focused on sentiment and semantic richness. That method was applied to the COCO-MS dataset, comprising approximately 150K images with segmented objects and corresponding crowd-sourced captions. We employed pre-trained models (Twitter-RoBERTa-base and BERT-base) to extract sentiment scores and variability of semantic embeddings from captions. The relation of the sentiment score and semantic variability with object categories was examined using multiple linear regression. Results indicate that while most captions were neutral, about 6% of the captions exhibited strong sentiment influenced by specific object categories. Semantic variability of within-image captions remained low and uncorrelated with object categories. Model-generated captions showed less than 1.5% of strong sentiment which was not influenced by object categories and did not correlate with the sentiment of the respective human-generated captions. This research demonstrates an approach to assess the quality of crowd- or worker-sourced captions informed by image content.
Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition,Artificial Intelligence,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to evaluate the authenticity and quality of image captions (i.e., image description texts). Specifically, researchers focus on evaluating the quality of image captions through sentiment analysis and semantic analysis. With the development of deep - learning technology, a large amount of labeled data is crucial for tasks such as natural language processing and computer vision. However, this data is usually obtained through crowdsourcing or data worker pools, and its authenticity and quality directly affect the performance of the training model. Therefore, this paper proposes a new method, aiming to evaluate the quality of these captions by analyzing the sentiment tendency and semantic richness in the image captions. In particular, it has studied about 150,000 images in the COCO - MS dataset and their corresponding crowdsourced captions. The research uses pre - trained Twitter - RoBERTa - base and BERT - base models to extract the sentiment scores of the captions and the variability of semantic embeddings, and analyzes the relationship between sentiment scores and object categories through multiple linear regression. In addition, it also compares the differences in emotional expression between human - generated captions and model - generated captions.