Optically-Validated Microvascular Phantom for Super-Resolution Ultrasound Imaging

Jaime Parra Raad,Daniel Lock,Yi-Yi Liu,Mark Solomon,Laura Peralta,Kirsten Christensen-Jeffries

2024-09-14

Abstract:Super-resolution ultrasound (SRUS) visualises microvasculature beyond the ultrasound diffraction limit (wavelength($\lambda$)/2) by localising and tracking spatially isolated microbubble contrast agents. SRUS phantoms typically consist of simple tube structures, where diameter channels below 100 $\mu$m are not available. Furthermore, these phantoms are generally fragile and unstable, have limited ground truth validation, and their simple structure limits the evaluation of SRUS algorithms. To aid SRUS development, robust and durable phantoms with known and physiologically relevant microvasculature are needed for repeatable SRUS testing. This work proposes a method to fabricate durable microvascular phantoms that allow optical gauging for SRUS validation. The methodology used a microvasculature negative print embedded in a Polydimethylsiloxane to fabricate a microvascular phantom. Branching microvascular phantoms with variable microvascular density were demonstrated with optically validated vessel diameters down to $\sim$ 60 $\mu$m ($\lambda$/5.8; $\lambda$ =$\sim$ 350 $\mu$m). SRUS imaging was performed and validated with optical measurements. The average SRUS error was 15.61 $\mu$m ($\lambda$/22) with a standard deviation error of 11.44 $\mu$m. The average error decreased to 7.93 $\mu$m ($\lambda$/44) once the number of localised microbubbles surpassed 1000 per estimated diameter. In addition, the less than 10$\%$ variance of acoustic and optical properties and the mechanical toughness of the phantoms measured a year after fabrication demonstrated their long-term durability. This work presents a method to fabricate durable and optically validated complex microvascular phantoms which can be used to quantify SRUS performance and facilitate its further development.

Medical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the challenges faced by super - resolution ultrasound imaging (SRUS) in verification and performance evaluation. Specifically, the existing SRUS phantoms have the following problems:

1. **Simple structure**: Most of the existing SRUS phantoms are composed of simple tubular structures and cannot simulate complex microvascular networks, especially microvessels with a diameter of less than 100 micrometers.
2. **Fragile and unstable**: These phantoms are usually relatively fragile, easily damaged, and difficult to perform long - term repeated tests.
3. **Lack of ground - truth verification**: The existing phantoms often lack accurate ground - truth verification, which limits the accurate evaluation of the performance of SRUS algorithms.
4. **Limited physiological relevance**: The existing phantom structures do not completely match the microvascular structures under actual physiological conditions, affecting their reliability in clinical applications.

To overcome these problems, this paper proposes a new method for manufacturing durable and optically - verified complex microvascular phantoms. These phantoms have the following characteristics:

- **Complex and physiologically relevant microvascular structures**: They can simulate branching and microvascular networks with different densities.
- **Durability**: The phantom materials have good mechanical strength and long - term stability and can maintain their performance even after one year.
- **Optical verification**: The microvascular diameter of the phantom is verified by optical measurement to ensure its accuracy.

Through this method, researchers hope to provide a reliable tool for quantitatively evaluating the performance of SRUS and promote its further development and clinical application.