Abstract:Under high perpendicular magnetic field and at low temperatures, graphene develops an insulating state at the charge neutrality point. This state, dubbed $\nu=0$, is due to the interplay between electronic interactions and the four-fold spin and valley degeneracies in the flat band formed by the $n=0$ Landau level. Determining the ground state of $\nu=0$, including its spin and valley polarization, has been a theoretical and experimental undertaking for almost two decades. Here, we present experiments probing the bulk thermal transport properties of monolayer graphene at $\nu=0$, which directly probe its ground state and collective excitations. We observe a vanishing bulk thermal transport, in contradiction with the expected ground state, predicted to have a finite thermal conductance even at very low temperature. Our result highlight the need for further investigations on the nature of $\nu=0$.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the bulk heat current of the quantum Hall ferromagnet disappears when the filling factor $\nu = 0$ in single - layer graphene. Specifically, the researchers experimentally probed the bulk heat - transfer characteristics of single - layer graphene in the $\nu = 0$ state to directly explore its ground state and collective excitation modes. The expected ground - state prediction should have a finite thermal conductivity even at extremely low temperatures, but the experimental results observed the disappearance of the bulk heat current, which is in contradiction to the theoretical prediction. Therefore, this study aims to reveal the true nature of the $\nu = 0$ state and explore whether there are gapless collective excitation modes. ### Background and Problem Under high perpendicular magnetic fields and low - temperature conditions, graphene forms an insulating state at the charge neutral point, which is called $\nu = 0$. This state is caused by the interaction between electron - electron interactions and the lifting of the four - fold spin and valley - degeneracy in the flat band formed at the $n = 0$ Landau level. Determining the ground state of $\nu = 0$, including its spin and valley polarizations, has been the focus of theoretical and experimental research. ### Experimental Methods The researchers used two different geometric structures to probe the bulk heat - transfer characteristics of single - layer graphene in the $\nu = 0$ state: 1. **Two - terminal device**: Heat and measure temperature changes through two floating metal contacts (source and detector). 2. **Corbino heat - transfer device**: Connect two graphene flakes embedded in a multi - layer heterostructure through a single floating metal contact, where one flake is used for the standard heat - transfer geometric structure and the other for the Corbino geometric structure. ### Experimental Results - **Two - terminal device**: In the $\nu = 0$ state, when the heating source contact is heated, the temperature of the detector contact hardly changes, indicating that the bulk heat current is very small. - **Corbino heat - transfer device**: In the $\nu = 0$ and $\nu = 2$ states, the temperature increases are almost the same, further confirming that the bulk heat current in the $\nu = 0$ state is very small. ### Discussion The experimental results are significantly different from the theoretical predictions, especially compared with the predicted thermal conductivity of the Cantor antiferromagnetic (CAF) phase. The experimentally observed thermal conductivity is much smaller. This has led to further exploration of the true nature of the $\nu = 0$ state. Possible explanations include: - The ground state of $\nu = 0$ may be a fully sub - lattice - polarized phase (FSP), which is the only phase that is both an electrical insulator and a thermal insulator. - The ground state may be a more complex Kekulé - distorted phase (KD), in which domains with different bond orders may exist, resulting in a significant reduction in thermal conductivity. - The observed disappearance of the heat current may be due to extrinsic factors, such as the quantization of collective modes or thermal interface resistance caused by device size. ### Conclusion This study experimentally observed the disappearance of the bulk heat current in single - layer graphene in the $\nu = 0$ state, which is inconsistent with theoretical predictions, suggesting that further theoretical and experimental research is needed to understand the true nature of the $\nu = 0$ state.

Vanishing bulk heat flow in the nu=0 quantum Hall ferromagnet in monolayer graphene

Vanishing bulk heat flow in the ν = 0 quantum Hall ferromagnet in monolayer graphene

Absence of heat flow in ν = 0 quantum Hall ferromagnet in bilayer graphene

Disorder and quantum transport of the helical quantum Hall phase in graphene

Topological Transition of Graphene from a Quantum Hall Metal to a Quantum Hall Insulator Atν= 0

Strong-Magnetic-Field Magnon Transport in Monolayer Graphene

Canted antiferromagnetic phase of the $ν=0$ quantum Hall state in bilayer graphene

Thermoelectric and Thermal Transport Properties of Graphene under Strong Magnetic Field

No heat flow in charge-neutral graphene

Heat Conductance of the Quantum Hall Bulk

Electric field control of superconductivity and quantized anomalous Hall effects in rhombohedral tetralayer graphene

Landau-Level Splitting in Graphene in High Magnetic Fields

Experimental Observation of Quantum Hall Effect and Berry's Phase in Graphene

Thermoelectric And Thermal Transport In Bilayer Graphene Systems

Spin-Polarized Nu=0 State Of Graphene: A Spin Superconductor

Experimental observation of the quantum Hall effect and Berry's phase in graphene

Graphene: from materials science to particle physics

Thermodynamics of free and bound magnons in graphene

Electronic thermal transport measurement in low-dimensional materials with graphene non-local noise thermometry