The Informal Labor of Content Creators: Situating Xiaohongshu's Key Opinion Consumers in Relationships to Marketers, Consumer Brands, and the Platform

Huiran Yi,Lu Xian
2024-09-13
Abstract:This paper critically examines flexible content creation conducted by Key Opinion Consumers (KOCs) on a prominent social media and e-commerce platform in China, Xiaohongshu (RED). Drawing on nine-month ethnographic work conducted online, we find that the production of the KOC role on RED is predicated on the interactions and negotiations among multiple stakeholders -- content creators, marketers, consumer brands (corporations), and the platform. KOCs are instrumental in RED influencer marketing tactics and amplify the mundane and daily life content popular on the platform. They navigate the dynamics in the triangulated relations with other stakeholders in order to secure economic opportunities for producing advertorial content, and yet, the labor involved in producing such content is deliberately obscured to make it appear as spontaneous, ordinary user posts for the sake of marketing campaigns. Meanwhile, the commercial value of their work is often underestimated and overshadowed in corporate paperwork, platform technological mechanisms, and business models, resulting in and reinforcing inadequate recognition and compensation of KOCs. We propose the concept of ``informal labor'' to offer a new lens to understand content creation labor that is indispensable yet unrecognized by the social media industry. We advocate for a contextualized and nuanced examination of how labor is valued and compensated and urge for better protections and working conditions for informal laborers like KOCs.
Social and Information Networks
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the "informal labor" of key opinion consumers (KOCs) in content creation on Xiaohongshu (RED for short), a well - known social media and e - commerce platform in China. Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following core questions: 1. **How do KOCs assume specific roles?** - Through ethnographic research methods, the paper describes in detail how KOCs cooperate with brands through content creation on the RED platform, as well as the challenges and opportunities they face in this process. 2. **What are the daily labors of content creators in digital cultural production?** - The paper deeply analyzes various small and daily labors involved in the content creation process of KOCs. Although these labors are crucial to the platform and brands, they are often overlooked and underestimated. 3. **What are the values and significance of this informal labor in the platform economy?** - The paper proposes the concept of "informal labor" to re - examine and understand the labor value of content creators in the platform economy. Although this labor is indispensable, it is often unrecognized and not properly compensated in the social media industry. ### Background and research motivation - **China's flexible employment policy**: The background of the paper involves China's high unemployment rate in recent years and flexible employment policies. The government encourages young people to engage in flexible employment, such as Internet marketing and content creation, to relieve employment pressure. - **Xiaohongshu (RED) platform**: As a platform integrating community and e - commerce, RED attracts a large number of users and content creators through marketing means such as "product promotion" (recommending products). KOCs, as a bridge between ordinary users and brands, have become an important part of platform marketing. ### Main contributions 1. **Analysis of the labor process**: By analyzing the labor process of KOCs, the paper reveals the complex relationships among various stakeholders in the platform economy. 2. **The concept of informal labor**: It proposes the concept of "informal labor", emphasizing that although this labor is indispensable, it is often masked by the platform and technical mechanisms, resulting in its value being underestimated. 3. **Impact on China's flexible employment policy**: It explores the impact of this informal labor on individual lives, especially how the younger generation copes with the employment crisis through this labor in the context of China's "flexible employment" policy. ### Methods - **Data collection**: The research adopts a long - term digital ethnographic method. The author conducted fieldwork on the RED platform from December 2021 to September 2023, including participant observation, interviews and data analysis. - **Data analysis**: Using grounded theory techniques to code and analyze interviews and field notes, and finally formed multiple themes, such as "key opinion consumer", "practical information", "monetization", etc. - **Positionality**: One of the researchers has a marketing background, which enables her to better understand the roles and challenges of KOCs in the platform economy. ### Conclusion By deeply exploring the informal labor of KOCs on the RED platform, the paper reveals the importance of this labor in the platform economy and the current situation of being overlooked. The research calls on all sectors of society to pay attention to and improve the working conditions and treatment of these content creators, so as to promote a more fair and sustainable platform economy.