Digital twin of a large-aspect-ratio Rayleigh-Bénard experiment: Role of thermal boundary conditions, measurement errors and uncertainties

Philipp Patrick Vieweg,Theo Käufer,Christian Cierpka,Jörg Schumacher

2024-09-13

Abstract:Albeit laboratory experiments and numerical simulations have proven themselves successful in enhancing our understanding of long-living large-scale flow structures in horizontally extended Rayleigh-Bénard convection, some discrepancies with respect to their size and induced heat transfer remain. This study traces these discrepancies back to their origins. We start by generating a digital twin of one standard experimental set-up. This twin is subsequently simplified in steps to understand the effect of non-ideal thermal boundary conditions, and the experimental measurement procedure is mimicked using numerical data. Although this allows explaining the increased observed size of the flow structures in the experiment relative to past numerical simulations, our data suggests that the vertical velocity magnitude has been underestimated in the experiments. A subsequent re-assessment of the latter's original data reveals an incorrect calibration model. The re-processed data show a relative increase in $u_{z}$ of roughly $24 \%$, resolving the previously observed discrepancies. This digital twin of a laboratory experiment for thermal convection at Rayleigh numbers $\Ra = \left\{ 2, 4, 7 \right\} \times 10^{5}$, a Prandtl number $\Pr = 7.1$, and an aspect ratio $\Gamma = 25$ highlights the role of different thermal boundary conditions as well as a reliable calibration and measurement procedure.

Fluid Dynamics,Computational Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve

The paper aims to address the discrepancies between laboratory experiments and numerical simulations by creating a digital twin model of the experiments. Specifically, the researchers focus on the formation and dynamic characteristics of large-scale flow structures in horizontally extended Rayleigh-Bénard convection. These flow structures are crucial for understanding heat transfer.

#### Research Background
- **Discrepancies between Experiments and Simulations**: Although laboratory experiments and numerical simulations have proven successful in enhancing our understanding of long-standing large-scale flow structures, there are still some differences in the size of the flow structures and the heat transfer they induce.
- **Impact of Non-Ideal Thermal Boundary Conditions**: These discrepancies can be traced back to non-ideal thermal boundary conditions and errors in the experimental measurement process.

#### Research Methods
1. **Digital Twin Model**: First, the researchers created a digital twin model of a standard experimental setup and gradually simplified the model to understand the impact of non-ideal thermal boundary conditions.
2. **Simulation of Experimental Measurement Process**: Numerical data was used to mimic the experimental measurement process, including systematic spatial averaging, error detection in mean solid-fluid interface temperature, and uncertainties in particle image thermometry.

#### Main Findings
- **Differences in Flow Structure Size**: Although the digital twin model explained the phenomenon of increased flow structure size observed in experiments, the vertical velocity component was underestimated in the experiments.
- **Reevaluation of Calibration Models**: A reevaluation of the original experimental data revealed that incorrect calibration models used in the past led to a systematic underestimation of the vertical velocity component by approximately 24%.

#### Impact Statement
- **Engineering and Industrial Applications**: The insights from this study have broad implications for engineering and industrial heat transfer applications, helping to improve thermal management systems in industrial processes and electronic devices, and providing key guidance for experimental setups in future fluid dynamics research.

### Summary
By creating a digital twin model of laboratory experiments, the paper explores in detail the impact of non-ideal thermal boundary conditions and reliable calibration and measurement procedures on experimental results, thereby addressing a series of discrepancies between experiments and simulations. This research provides important references for future experimental design.