$E\times B$ shear suppression of microtearing based transport in spherical tokamaks

B.S. Patel,M.R. Hardman,D. Kennedy,M. Giacomin,D. Dickinson,C.M. Roach

2024-09-13

Abstract:Electromagnetic microtearing modes (MTMs) have been observed in many different spherical tokamak regimes. Understanding how these and other electromagnetic modes nonlinearly saturate is likely critical in understanding the confinement of a high $\beta$ spherical tokamak (ST). Equilibrium $E\times B$ sheared flows have sometimes been found to significantly suppress low $\beta$ ion scale transport in both gyrokinetic simulations and in experiment. This work aims to understand the conditions under which $E\times B$ sheared flow impacts on the saturation of MTM simulations. Two experimental regimes are examined from MAST and NSTX, on surfaces that have unstable MTMs. The MTM driven transport on a local flux surface in MAST is shown to be more resilient to suppression via $E\times B$ shear, compared to the case from NSTX where the MTM transport is found to be significantly suppressed. This difference in the response to flow shear is explained through the impact of magnetic shear, $\hat{s}$ on the MTM linear growth rate dependence on ballooning angle, $\theta_0$. At low $\hat{s}$, the growth rate depends weakly on $\theta_0$, but at higher $\hat{s}$, the MTM growth rate peaks at $\theta_0 = 0$, with regions of stability at higher $\theta_0$. Equilibrium $E\times B$ sheared flows act to advect the $\theta_0$ of a mode in time, providing a mechanism which suppresses the transport from these modes when they become stable. The dependence of $\gamma^{MTM}$ on $\theta_0$ is in qualitative agreement with a recent theory [M.R. Hardman et al (2023)] at low $\beta$ when $q\sim1$, but the agreement worsens at higher $q$ where the theory breaks down. This work highlights the important role of the safety factor profile in determining the impact of equilibrium $E\times B$ shear on the saturation level of MTM turbulence.

Plasma Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how electromagnetic micro - tearing modes (MTMs) are affected by the equilibrium E × B shear flow in spherical tokamaks. Specifically, the paper explores the influence of E × B shear flow on the saturation degree of MTMs under different conditions, especially how E × B shear flow suppresses MTM - driven transport when the magnetic shear (\(\hat{s}\)) is high. By comparing the data in two experimental devices, MAST and NSTX, the study found that the suppression effect of E × B shear flow on MTMs is related to magnetic shear and is more significant under high - magnetic - shear conditions. In addition, the paper also evaluates the effectiveness of the recently proposed theoretical model in explaining these phenomena and discusses the importance of these findings for optimizing the design of spherical tokamaks.

### Main research contents of the paper:
1. **Background introduction**:
- Electromagnetic micro - tearing modes (MTMs) have been observed in various spherical tokamak (ST) designs, especially in the core and edge regions.
- Understanding the nonlinear saturation mechanisms of these modes is crucial for improving the confinement performance of high - β spherical tokamaks.
- The equilibrium E × B shear flow can sometimes significantly suppress the low - β ion - scale transport, but its effect varies in different experiments.

2. **Research objectives**:
- To explore the influence of E × B shear flow on the saturation degree of MTMs under different conditions.
- To analyze the influence of magnetic shear (\(\hat{s}\)) on the linear growth rate of MTMs.
- To evaluate the suppression effect of E × B shear flow under high - magnetic - shear conditions.

3. **Experimental methods**:
- Use the CGYRO code to conduct linear and nonlinear simulations to study the MTM behavior in the two experimental devices, MAST and NSTX.
- Analyze the growth rate and stability of MTMs by changing parameters such as magnetic shear (\(\hat{s}\)) and electron temperature gradient (\(\beta_e\)).

4. **Main findings**:
- In the MAST device, the growth rate of MTMs has a weak dependence on the ballooning angle (\(\theta_0\)), so the influence of E × B shear flow on it is limited.
- In the NSTX device, high magnetic shear (\(\hat{s}\)) makes the growth rate of MTMs more dependent on \(\theta_0\), and E × B shear flow can significantly suppress MTM - driven transport.
- Magnetic shear (\(\hat{s}\)) has an important influence on the stability of MTMs, and under high - magnetic - shear conditions, the suppression effect of E × B shear flow is more obvious.

5. **Verification of theoretical model**:
- The paper evaluates the effectiveness of the theoretical model proposed by Hardman et al. in explaining the dependence of MTM growth rate on \(\theta_0\).
- It is found that under low \(\hat{s}\) conditions, the theoretical model agrees well with the experimental results; while under high \(\hat{s}\) conditions, the performance of the theoretical model deteriorates.

6. **Conclusion**:
- This study emphasizes the important role of the magnetic shear profile in determining the influence of E × B shear flow on the MTM saturation level.
- Optimizing the magnetic shear profile can effectively control the stability of MTMs, thereby improving the confinement performance of spherical tokamaks.

Through these studies, the paper provides important insights for understanding MTM behavior in spherical tokamaks and provides theoretical support for future experimental design and optimization.