Minimizing Selection Bias in Inclusive Jets in Heavy-Ion Collisions with Energy Correlators

Carlota Andres,Jack Holguin,Raghav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli,Jussi Viinikainen

2024-10-02

Abstract:The first-ever measurement of energy correlators within inclusive jets produced in heavy-ion collisions, revealed by the CMS Collaboration, shows a clear enhancement at large angles relative to the proton-proton (p-p) baseline. However, interpreting this enhancement is complicated due to selection bias from energy loss, which also distorts the energy correlator heavy-ion to p-p ratio in the hadronization region, hindering our understanding of parton/hadron dynamics in a colored medium. In this Letter, we introduce a new ratio of energy correlator observables that removes the leading effects of selection bias from the two-point energy correlator spectrum (E2C). Pythia and Herwig simulations show that the impact of selection bias in the E2C is reduced by an order of magnitude, while sensitivity to any other medium modifications is retained. This quantity can be obtained directly from the experimental measurements presented by CMS, as illustrated in the accompanying note.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment,Nuclear Experiment,Nuclear Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the selection bias present in the measurement of the two-point energy correlation spectrum (E2C) of inclusive jets in heavy-ion collisions. Specifically:

1. **Large-Angle Enhancement**: In central to semi-peripheral lead-lead (Pb-Pb) collisions, the two-point energy correlation spectrum shows significant enhancement in the large-angle region compared to proton-proton (p-p) collisions. This enhancement may be caused by effects such as medium-induced splitting, transverse momentum broadening, and medium response, but its exact nature is not yet fully understood.

2. **Angular Shift Issue**: At the same reconstructed transverse momentum \( p_T \), the E2C spectrum of inclusive jets in Pb-Pb collisions shifts to smaller angles compared to the spectrum in p-p collisions. This shift is due to selection bias, as heavy-ion jets lose energy in the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), leading to jet samples being compared at the same \( p_T \) actually originating from different hard scales.

To eliminate the impact of these selection biases, the paper proposes a new method of energy correlation observable ratios, which directly cancels the main selection bias effects by constructing double ratios. This method has been validated in Pythia and Herwig simulations, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing the impact of selection bias by an order of magnitude while retaining sensitivity to other medium modifications. This method can be directly applied to CMS experimental data, allowing for a more accurate study of QGP modifications to jet substructure.