Urban context and delivery performance: Modelling service time for cargo bikes and vans across diverse urban environments

Maxwell Schrader,Navish Kumar,Esben Sørig,Soonmyeong Yoon,Akash Srivastava,Kai Xu,Maria Astefanoaei,Nicolas Collignon

2024-08-27

Abstract:Light goods vehicles (LGV) used extensively in the last mile of delivery are one of the leading polluters in cities. Cargo-bike logistics and Light Electric Vehicles (LEVs) have been put forward as a high impact candidate for replacing LGVs. Studies have estimated over half of urban van deliveries being replaceable by cargo-bikes, due to their faster speeds, shorter parking times and more efficient routes across cities. However, the logistics sector suffers from a lack of publicly available data, particularly pertaining to cargo-bike deliveries, thus limiting the understanding of their potential benefits. Specifically, service time (which includes cruising for parking, and walking to destination) is a major, but often overlooked component of delivery time modelling. The aim of this study is to establish a framework for measuring the performance of delivery vehicles, with an initial focus on modelling service times of vans and cargo-bikes across diverse urban environments. We introduce two datasets that allow for in-depth analysis and modelling of service times of cargo bikes and use existing datasets to reason about differences in delivery performance across vehicle types. We introduce a modelling framework to predict the service times of deliveries based on urban context. We employ Uber's H3 index to divide cities into hexagonal cells and aggregate OpenStreetMap tags for each cell, providing a detailed assessment of urban context. Leveraging this spatial grid, we use GeoVex to represent micro-regions as points in a continuous vector space, which then serve as input for predicting vehicle service times. We show that geospatial embeddings can effectively capture urban contexts and facilitate generalizations to new contexts and cities. Our methodology addresses the challenge of limited comparative data available for different vehicle types within the same urban settings.

Computers and Society,Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve the problem of pollution caused by light - goods vehicles (LGVs) in the last - mile delivery in cities, especially in urban environments. Specifically, the author focuses on how to reduce urban carbon emissions and traffic congestion by replacing traditional vans with cargo bikes and light - electric vehicles (LEVs). However, the current logistics industry lacks public and detailed data, especially delivery data on cargo bikes, which limits the understanding of their potential advantages.

#### Main research questions:
1. **Service - time modeling**: Service time (including the time to find a parking space, the time to walk to the destination, etc.) is an important factor affecting the overall delivery efficiency, especially in high - density urban environments. Existing research often ignores this crucial factor.
2. **Data scarcity**: Currently, there is very limited data on the performance comparison between cargo bikes and vans in the same urban environment, making it difficult to accurately assess the advantages and disadvantages of the two.
3. **Influence of urban context**: Different urban environments (such as population density, road types, building distributions, etc.) have a significant impact on the service time of delivery vehicles, but these impacts have not been fully studied.

#### Research purposes:
- **Establish a framework**: Develop a framework that can measure the performance of different types of delivery vehicles (such as vans and cargo bikes) in different urban environments, with a particular focus on service - time modeling.
- **Provide data support**: Fill the gap in current research on cargo - bike delivery data by introducing new data sets and provide a basis for subsequent research.
- **Prediction model**: Use machine - learning methods, combined with urban - context features, to predict the service time of different types of vehicles, thereby improving the prediction accuracy of delivery efficiency.

### Method overview:
- **Introduction of data sets**: The author introduced two new data sets, namely the cargo - bike delivery data from London and Brussels, and used the existing van - delivery data for comparative analysis.
- **Geospatial embedding**: Use Uber's H3 index to divide the city into hexagonal grids and combine OpenStreetMap tags to generate a detailed geospatial - embedding representation.
- **Model development**: Based on the above data and geospatial embedding, develop a machine - learning model for predicting the service time of different types of vehicles.

### Results and contributions:
- **Discover differences**: The research shows that the urban context has a significant impact on the service time of vans, while cargo bikes are less affected by this.
- **Preliminary verification**: The model demonstrates the ability to predict service time in new urban contexts, providing a direction for further research.
- **Emphasize the importance of data**: Point out that more detailed data collection is important for understanding delivery efficiency, especially in urban - logistics planning.

Through these studies, the author hopes to promote the development of more environmentally - friendly and efficient last - mile delivery methods, especially in high - density urban environments.