Abstract:Meals are a central (and messy) part of family life. Previous design framings for mealtime technologies have focused on supporting dietary needs or social and celebratory interactions at the dinner table; however, family meals involve the coordination of many activities and complicated family dynamics. In this paper, we report on findings from interviews and design sessions with 18 families from the Midwestern United States (including both partners/parents and children) to uncover important family differences and tensions that arise around domestic meal experiences. Drawing on feminist theory, we unpack the work of feeding a family as a form of care, drawing attention to the social and emotional complexity of family meals. Critically situating our data within current design narratives, we propose the sensitizing concepts of generative and systemic discontents as a productive way towards troubling the design space of family-food interaction to contend with the struggles that are a part of everyday family meal experiences.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Current home dining technology designs have failed to fully consider the complex interactions among family members, emotional needs, as well as the contradictions and tensions existing in daily life. Specifically, although existing research and technology have focused on how to support the sociality and celebratory nature of family dinners through technology (such as promoting positive family interactions and healthy eating habits), these designs often overlook the inherent challenges and difficulties in the family dining process, especially those related to family internal differences, uneven labor distribution, and sociocultural factors.
### Core Problems of the Paper
1. **Limitations of Existing Design Frameworks**:
- **Corrective Design Framework**: Many studies regard technology as a tool to solve information or work challenges (such as low cooking efficiency) or correct bad behaviors (such as unhealthy eating).
- **Celebratory Design Framework**: Other studies emphasize creating positive dining experiences through technology, such as enhancing social interactions among family members and the pleasure of eating together.
2. **Insufficiently Understood Complexity of Family Dining**:
- Family dining is not just a process of satisfying basic needs or enjoying food, but involves complex family relationships and social dynamics. For example, family members may have different food preferences, nutritional goals, and even conflicting needs emotionally or physically.
- For many parents (especially women), although smart kitchen technology promises to reduce housework, family dining is still a time - consuming and stressful task, often making them feel that their personal needs are not met.
3. **Influence of Social and Cultural Issues**:
- Social and cultural issues such as food insecurity faced by some families and gender - unequal housework division further exacerbate the complexity of family dining. These issues are not only common but also deeply affect the quality of family life.
### Solutions
To understand and design home dining technology more comprehensively, the author proposes two key concepts:
1. **Generative Discontents**:
- It refers to the daily interpersonal differences or tensions within the family, which can be improved through negotiation or resolution to improve family relationships. For example, different food preferences of family members can be dealt with through better communication and coordination.
2. **Systemic Discontents**:
- It involves food - related challenges related to broader social and cultural factors, such as food insecurity or gender inequality in housework. These problems may require more resistant and transformative interventions.
By introducing these two concepts, the author hopes to provide new perspectives for the HCI/CSCW community, helping to design more nuanced and supportive family dining technologies, so as to better cope with the complexity and diversity in family life.
### Conclusion
Through interviews and design meetings with 18 American families, this paper reveals various challenges and contradictions in the family dining process and proposes a new design concept, that is, not only to pay attention to the positive aspects of family dining, but also to seriously deal with the "troubles" and "discontents" in it, in order to achieve more inclusive and human - centered technology design.