Information Asymmetry Index: The View of Market Analysts

Roberto Frota Decourt,Heitor Almeida,Philippe Protin,Matheus R. C. Gonzalez

2024-09-10

Abstract:The purpose of the research was to build an index of informational asymmetry with market and firm proxies that reflect the analysts' perception of the level of informational asymmetry of companies. The proposed method consists of the construction of an algorithm based on the Elo rating and captures the perception of the analyst that choose, between two firms, the one they consider to have better information. After we have the informational asymmetry index, we run a regression model with our rating as dependent variable and proxies used by the literature as the independent variable to have a model that can be used for other researches that need to measure the level of informational asymmetry of a company. Our model presented a good fit between our index and the proxies used to measure informational asymmetry and we find four significant variables: coverage, volatility, Tobin q, and size.

General Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to construct an Information Asymmetry Index (IAI) that can reflect market analysts' perception of the degree of information asymmetry. Specifically, the paper solves the problem in the following ways:

1. **Constructing the Information Asymmetry Index**:
- Use the Elo rating algorithm to evaluate the information disclosure quality among different companies based on the choices of market analysts.
- Through market analysts' selection of companies with better information disclosure in pairwise comparisons, gradually adjust the Elo scores of each company, thus forming an index that reflects the degree of information asymmetry.

2. **Verifying the Validity of the Index**:
- Through regression analysis, take the constructed IAI as the dependent variable and regress it with proxy variables commonly used in the literature to measure information asymmetry (such as coverage, volatility, Tobin q value, and company size, etc.) to verify the validity and robustness of IAI.
- Conduct tests in three aspects: external analysis, internal analysis, and market microstructure to ensure that IAI can comprehensively reflect different aspects of information asymmetry.

3. **Innovation of the Method**:
- Previous studies usually rely on proxy variables such as financial analysts' forecasts, companies' investment opportunities, and the existence of informed and uninformed traders in daily stock prices to measure information asymmetry.
- This paper provides a new and more comprehensive method to measure information asymmetry by directly investigating market analysts' perceptions, aiming to improve the external validity of the research.

4. **Practical Applications**:
- This index can be used in other studies to help researchers more accurately measure the degree of information asymmetry in companies, so as to better understand the impact of information asymmetry on corporate governance, cost of capital, profitability, etc.

In summary, the main objective of this paper is to construct a reliable Information Asymmetry Index from the perspective of market analysts and verify its validity and applicability.