Abstract:We study the problem of matching markets with ties, where one side of the market does not necessarily have strict preferences over members at its other side. For example, workers do not always have strict preferences over jobs, students can give the same ranking for different schools and more. In particular, assume w.l.o.g. that workers' preferences are determined by their utility from being matched to each job, which might admit ties. Notably, in contrast to classical two-sided markets with strict preferences, there is no longer a single stable matching that simultaneously maximizes the utility for all workers. We aim to guarantee each worker the largest possible share from the utility in her best possible stable matching. We call the ratio between the worker's best possible stable utility and its assigned utility the \emph{Optimal Stable Share} (OSS)-ratio. We first prove that distributions over stable matchings cannot guarantee an OSS-ratio that is sublinear in the number of workers. Instead, randomizing over possibly non-stable matchings, we show how to achieve a tight logarithmic OSS-ratio. Then, we analyze the case where the real utility is not necessarily known and can only be approximated. In particular, we provide an algorithm that guarantees a similar fraction of the utility compared to the best possible utility. Finally, we move to a bandit setting, where we select a matching at each round and only observe the utilities for matches we perform. We show how to utilize our results for approximate utilities to gracefully interpolate between problems without ties and problems with statistical ties (small suboptimality gaps).

Note on solving one-to-one matching models with linear transferable utility

The matching problem with linear transfers is equivalent to a hide-and-seek game

Matching Function Equilibria with Partial Assignment: Existence, Uniqueness and Estimation

Estimating separable matching models

Matching in Closed-Form: Equilibrium, Identification, and Comparative Statics

Matching under Imperfectly Transferable Utility

Competitive Equilibria in Two Sided Matching Markets with Non-transferable Utilities

Cupid's Invisible Hand: Social Surplus and Identification in Matching Models

Substitutability, equilibrium transport, and matching models

Identification and Estimation in Many‐to‐One Two‐Sided Matching Without Transfers

Nash-Bargaining-Based Models for Matching Markets: One-Sided and Two-Sided; Fisher and Arrow-Debreu

Matching markets with middlemen under transferable utility

Identification and Estimation in Many-to-one Two-sided Matching without Transfers

Existence of a Competitive Equilibrium with Substitutes, with Applications to Matching and Discrete Choice Models

Stable matching as transportation

Competitive Equilibria in Matching Markets with Budgets

A Note on Matching Variables to Equations

Stable matching in a common generalization of the marriage and assignment models

Stable Matching with Ties: Approximation Ratios and Learning

Stable Matching Games

Individual Rationality Conditions of Identifying Matching Costs in Transferable Utility Matching Games