Exact equality of the MSEs for two types of nonlinear adaptive systems: Saturation and dead-zone types

Seiji Miyoshi,Yua Yamaguchi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2409.05281
2024-09-09
Abstract:Adaptive signal processing systems, commonly utilized in applications such as active noise control and acoustic echo cancellation, often encompass nonlinearities due to hardware components such as loudspeakers, microphones, and amplifiers. Examining the impact of these nonlinearities on the overall performance of adaptive systems is critically important. In this study, we employ a statistical-mechanical method to investigate the behaviors of adaptive systems, each containing an unknown system with a nonlinearity in its output. We specifically address two types of nonlinearity: saturation and dead-zone types. We analyze both the dynamic and steady-state behaviors of these systems under the effect of such nonlinearities. Our findings indicate that when the saturation value is equal to the dead-zone width, the mean square errors (MSEs) in steady states are identical for both nonlinearity types. Furthermore, we derive a self-consistent equation to obtain the saturation value and dead-zone width that maximize the steady-state MSE. We theoretically clarify that these values depend on neither the step size nor the variance of background noise.
Signal Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the behavior of adaptive signal processing systems with nonlinear outputs. Specifically, it studies two types of nonlinearities: saturation - type and dead - zone - type. The author uses statistical mechanics methods to analyze the dynamic and steady - state behaviors of these systems and attempts to answer the following key questions: 1. **The influence of different nonlinearities on system performance**: - How do saturation - type and dead - zone - type nonlinearities affect the mean - square error (MSE) of the adaptive system? - When the saturation value is equal to the dead - zone width, are the steady - state MSEs of these two nonlinear types the same? 2. **Determining the optimal parameters**: - How can we find the saturation value and dead - zone width that maximize the steady - state MSE? - Do these optimal parameters depend on the step size or the variance of the background noise? ### Main contributions - **Theoretical analysis**: Through statistical mechanics methods, the dynamic and steady - state behaviors of adaptive systems with saturation - type and dead - zone - type nonlinearities are analyzed respectively. - **MSE equivalence**: It is found that when the saturation value is equal to the dead - zone width, the steady - state MSEs of the two nonlinear types are exactly the same. - **Self - consistent equations**: Self - consistent equations are derived to determine the saturation value and dead - zone width that maximize the steady - state MSE. These values are independent of the step size and the variance of the background noise. ### Conclusions This study shows that under specific conditions (i.e., when the saturation value is equal to the dead - zone width), the mean - square errors of the two nonlinear - type adaptive systems in the steady state are exactly the same. In addition, the author also obtains a self - consistent equation to determine the nonlinear parameters that maximize the steady - state MSE and verifies that these parameters are independent of the step size and the variance of the background noise. ### Formula summary - **MSE expression**: \[ \text{MSE}=\left\langle(f(x)-y + \xi)^2\right\rangle \] where \( f(x) \) is a nonlinear function, \( y \) is the output of the adaptive filter, and \( \xi \) is the background noise. - **Self - consistent equation**: \[ 1+\frac{r}{2\rho^2\sigma_g^2}\cdot\frac{\sqrt{\pi}\cdot\text{erf}\left(\frac{\Box}{\sqrt{2\rho^2\sigma_g^2}}\right)}{\exp\left(-\frac{\Box^2}{2\rho^2\sigma_g^2}\right)} = 1 \] where \( \Box \) represents the saturation value \( S \) or the dead - zone width \( D \), and \( \rho \) and \( \sigma_g \) are the normalization parameters of the input signal respectively. Through these studies, the author provides an important theoretical basis for understanding and optimizing adaptive systems containing nonlinear elements.