Abstract:Matrix completion tackles the task of predicting missing values in a low-rank matrix based on a sparse set of observed entries. It is often assumed that the observation pattern is generated uniformly at random or has a very specific structure tuned to a given algorithm. There is still a gap in our understanding when it comes to arbitrary sampling patterns. Given an arbitrary sampling pattern, we introduce a matrix completion algorithm based on network flows in the bipartite graph induced by the observation pattern. For additive matrices, the particular flow we used is the electrical flow and we establish error upper bounds customized to each entry as a function of the observation set, along with matching minimax lower bounds. Our results show that the minimax squared error for recovery of a particular entry in the matrix is proportional to the effective resistance of the corresponding edge in the graph. Furthermore, we show that our estimator is equivalent to the least squares estimator. We apply our estimator to the two-way fixed effects model and show that it enables us to accurately infer individual causal effects and the unit-specific and time-specific confounders. For rank-$1$ matrices, we use edge-disjoint paths to form an estimator that achieves minimax optimal estimation when the sampling is sufficiently dense. Our discovery introduces a new family of estimators parametrized by network flows, which provide a fine-grained and intuitive understanding of the impact of the given sampling pattern on the relative difficulty of estimation at an entry-specific level. This graph-based approach allows us to quantify the inherent complexity of matrix completion for individual entries, rather than relying solely on global measures of performance.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to provide specific error bounds for each matrix entry when performing matrix estimation in an arbitrary sampling pattern. Traditional methods usually assume that the observations are uniformly distributed or have a certain specific structure, but these assumptions are often not valid in practical applications, resulting in existing methods being ineffective when dealing with non - uniform or arbitrary sampling patterns. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following two aspects:
1. **Matrix Estimation in Arbitrary Sampling Patterns**: The paper proposes a new algorithm based on network flow, which can estimate low - rank matrices in arbitrary sampling patterns and provide specific error bounds for each entry. This algorithm can adapt to various different sampling patterns, not just uniform or specific - structure patterns.
2. **Entry - Specific Error Analysis**: The paper not only provides overall error analysis but also specific error bounds for each matrix entry. These error bounds are related to the effective resistance and minimum cut in the graph, enabling a more refined understanding of the estimation difficulty of different entries.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Network Flow Algorithm**:
- Proposes an algorithm based on network flow for estimating the missing values of additive matrices and rank - 1 matrices in arbitrary sampling patterns.
- These algorithms can provide entry - specific estimation guarantees that match the minimax lower bounds.
- Theoretical results show that the stronger the connection of the vertices corresponding to the entries in the bipartite graph, the smaller the estimation error. This reveals the connection between matrix completion and graph theory.
2. **Estimation of Additive Matrices**:
- Based on regarding the bipartite graph as an electrical network and applying unit current, proposes an electrical flow estimator.
- Proves that the entry - specific error upper bound matches the local minimax lower bound within a logarithmic factor.
- The electrical flow estimator is equivalent to the least - squares estimator, which means that the least - squares estimator also reaches the minimax lower bound for each entry.
- When applied to the two - way fixed - effect model, this algorithm can predict individual causal effects rather than aggregate effects and provides provable entry - specific guarantees.
3. **Estimation of Rank - 1 Matrices**:
- Constructs a network flow estimator using edge - disjoint paths in the graph.
- The entry - specific error upper bound depends on the connectivity of the vertices, especially the number of maximum edge - disjoint paths and the maximum length of these paths.
- When the observations are dense enough or have certain structures, the estimator reaches minimax optimality.
- Demonstrates minimax optimality through minimum - cut construction, further clarifying the relationship between estimation quality and minimum cut.
### Related Literature
- **Matrix Completion**: Early studies usually assume that the observations are uniformly distributed in the matrix, and the goal is to derive the conditions for exact recovery in the noiseless case or to characterize the mean - squared error in the noisy case. However, these assumptions are often not valid in practical applications, so non - uniform or deterministic observation patterns need to be considered.
- **Panel Data**: In causal inference, when using panel data to estimate treatment effects, the observation and treatment patterns are often non - uniform. Traditional panel data methods usually assume simple block or step - treatment patterns, but the observation and treatment patterns in reality may be very irregular.
### Graph Construction
For a fixed observation pattern \(\Omega\), construct an undirected bipartite graph \(G(\Omega)=(V, E(\Omega))\), where the edges of the graph are given by the sparse pattern of \(\Omega\). The left vertices represent rows and the right vertices represent columns. If \(\Omega_{ij} = 1\), then the vertices \(u_i\) and \(v_j\) are adjacent.
### Network Flow Estimators
- **Single - Path Estimator**: Constructs an unbiased estimator by alternately adding and subtracting observations on the path.
- **Multi - Path Estimator**: When there are multiple paths in the graph, the estimates on each path can be aggregated through network flow to fully utilize the available information.
- **Electrical Flow Estimator**: Among all unbiased flow estimators, the electrical flow estimator is optimal because it minimizes the variance. The variance of the electrical flow estimator is proportional to the effective resistance, reflecting the connectivity between vertices.
### Conclusion
This paper solves the problem of matrix estimation in arbitrary sampling patterns by introducing an algorithm based on network flow and provides specific error bounds for each entry. These results are not only theoretically significant.