A typology of activities over a century of urban growth

Julie Gravier,Marc Barthelemy

2024-09-05

Abstract:Contemporary literature on the dynamics of economic activities in growing cities mainly focused on a few years or decades time frames. Using a new geo-historical database constructed from historical directories with about 1 million entries, we present a comprehensive analysis of the dynamics of activities in a major city, Paris, over almost a century (1829-1907). Our analysis suggests that activities that accompany city growth can be classified in different categories according to their dynamics and their scaling with population: (i) linear for everyday needs of residents (food stores, clothing retailers, health care practitioners), (ii) sublinear for public services (legal, administrative, educational), (iii) superlinear for the city's specific features (passing fads, specialization, timely needs). The dynamics of these activities is in addition very sensitive to historical perturbations such as large scale public works or political conflicts. These results shed light on the evolution of activities, a crucial component of growing cities.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: by analyzing the dynamics of economic activities in Paris over nearly a century from 1829 to 1907, it explores the patterns of changes in different activities during urban growth and their relationship with population size. Specifically, the author utilizes a new historical geographic database containing approximately 1 million records to conduct a comprehensive analysis of Paris's economic activities, aiming to:

1. **Classify Activities**: Categorize activities accompanying urban growth into different categories based on their dynamics and relationship with population size.
- Linear relationship (β ≈ 1): Such as food stores, clothing retailers, healthcare practitioners, etc., these activities primarily meet the daily needs of residents.
- Sublinear relationship (β < 1): Such as public services (legal, administrative, educational services), these activities typically exhibit economies of scale.
- Superlinear relationship (β > 1): Such as specific urban features (trends, specialization, timely demands), these activities are usually related to the city's development stage and specific period demands.

2. **Analyze the Impact of Historical Disturbances**: Study the impact of historical events such as large-scale public works (e.g., Haussmann's renovation) and political conflicts (e.g., the Franco-Prussian War and the Paris Commune) on the dynamics of urban activities.

3. **Understand the Core Mechanisms of Urban Development**: Reveal the core mechanisms of urban development by analyzing the dynamic changes of different types of activities, especially how activities related to specific urban features evolve over time.

4. **Provide a Long-term Perspective**: Unlike most studies that focus only on a few years or decades, this paper offers a historical perspective spanning nearly a century, helping to more comprehensively understand the evolution of urban systems.

In summary, through detailed historical data analysis, this paper attempts to reveal the dynamic patterns of different economic activities during urban growth and how these activities are influenced by historical events, thereby providing new insights for urban science research.