Abstract:Reward models have been increasingly critical for improving the reasoning capability of LLMs. Existing research has shown that a well-trained reward model can substantially improve model performances at inference time via search. However, the potential of reward models during RL training time still remains largely under-explored. It is currently unclear whether these reward models can provide additional training signals to enhance the reasoning capabilities of LLMs in RL training that uses sparse success rewards, which verify the correctness of solutions. In this work, we evaluate popular reward models for RL training, including the Outcome-supervised Reward Model (ORM) and the Process-supervised Reward Model (PRM), and train a collection of LLMs for math problems using RL by combining these learned rewards with success rewards. Surprisingly, even though these learned reward models have strong inference-time performances, they may NOT help or even hurt RL training, producing worse performances than LLMs trained with the success reward only. Our analysis reveals that an LLM can receive high rewards from some of these reward models by repeating correct but unnecessary reasoning steps, leading to a severe reward hacking issue. Therefore, we introduce two novel reward refinement techniques, including Clipping and Delta. The key idea is to ensure the accumulative reward of any reasoning trajectory is upper-bounded to keep a learned reward model effective without being exploited. We evaluate our techniques with multiple reward models over a set of 1.5B and 7B LLMs on MATH and GSM8K benchmarks and demonstrate that with a carefully designed reward function, RL training without any additional supervised tuning can improve all the evaluated LLMs, including the state-of-the-art 7B LLM Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct on MATH and GSM8K benchmarks.

Large Language Models as Efficient Reward Function Searchers for Custom-Environment Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning

A Large Language Model-Driven Reward Design Framework via Dynamic Feedback for Reinforcement Learning

Self-Refined Large Language Model as Automated Reward Function Designer for Deep Reinforcement Learning in Robotics

Improving Large Language Models via Fine-grained Reinforcement Learning with Minimum Editing Constraint

Secrets of RLHF in Large Language Models Part II: Reward Modeling

Online Intrinsic Rewards for Decision Making Agents from Large Language Model Feedback

Few-shot In-Context Preference Learning Using Large Language Models

Latent Reward: LLM-Empowered Credit Assignment in Episodic Reinforcement Learning

LongReward: Improving Long-context Large Language Models with AI Feedback

Towards Socially and Morally Aware RL agent: Reward Design With LLM

REvolve: Reward Evolution with Large Language Models using Human Feedback

Generating and Evolving Reward Functions for Highway Driving with Large Language Models

Learning Reward for Robot Skills Using Large Language Models via Self-Alignment

LIRE: listwise reward enhancement for preference alignment

Reward Design with Language Models

RL-VLM-F: Reinforcement Learning from Vision Language Foundation Model Feedback

Words as Beacons: Guiding RL Agents with High-Level Language Prompts

World Models with Hints of Large Language Models for Goal Achieving

Fine-Tuning Language Models with Reward Learning on Policy

On Designing Effective RL Reward at Training Time for LLM Reasoning