Abstract:Importance: Large language models (LLMs) can assist in various health care activities, but current evaluation approaches may not adequately identify the most useful application areas. Objective: To summarize existing evaluations of LLMs in health care in terms of 5 components: (1) evaluation data type, (2) health care task, (3) natural language processing (NLP) and natural language understanding (NLU) tasks, (4) dimension of evaluation, and (5) medical specialty. Data sources: A systematic search of PubMed and Web of Science was performed for studies published between January 1, 2022, and February 19, 2024. Study selection: Studies evaluating 1 or more LLMs in health care. Data extraction and synthesis: Three independent reviewers categorized studies via keyword searches based on the data used, the health care tasks, the NLP and NLU tasks, the dimensions of evaluation, and the medical specialty. Results: Of 519 studies reviewed, published between January 1, 2022, and February 19, 2024, only 5% used real patient care data for LLM evaluation. The most common health care tasks were assessing medical knowledge such as answering medical licensing examination questions (44.5%) and making diagnoses (19.5%). Administrative tasks such as assigning billing codes (0.2%) and writing prescriptions (0.2%) were less studied. For NLP and NLU tasks, most studies focused on question answering (84.2%), while tasks such as summarization (8.9%) and conversational dialogue (3.3%) were infrequent. Almost all studies (95.4%) used accuracy as the primary dimension of evaluation; fairness, bias, and toxicity (15.8%), deployment considerations (4.6%), and calibration and uncertainty (1.2%) were infrequently measured. Finally, in terms of medical specialty area, most studies were in generic health care applications (25.6%), internal medicine (16.4%), surgery (11.4%), and ophthalmology (6.9%), with nuclear medicine (0.6%), physical medicine (0.4%), and medical genetics (0.2%) being the least represented. Conclusions and relevance: Existing evaluations of LLMs mostly focus on accuracy of question answering for medical examinations, without consideration of real patient care data. Dimensions such as fairness, bias, and toxicity and deployment considerations received limited attention. Future evaluations should adopt standardized applications and metrics, use clinical data, and broaden focus to include a wider range of tasks and specialties.

Towards Leveraging Large Language Models for Automated Medical Q&A Evaluation

Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey

Large Language Model-Based Evaluation of Medical Question Answering Systems: Algorithm Development and Case Study

Using Large Language Models to Evaluate Biomedical Query-Focused Summarisation

MedLM: Exploring Language Models for Medical Question Answering Systems

Towards Expert-Level Medical Question Answering with Large Language Models

Large language models encode clinical knowledge

Enhancing Healthcare through Large Language Models: A Study on Medical Question Answering

Improving Clinical Expertise in Large Language Models Using Electronic Medical Records

Critical Care Studies Using Large Language Models Based on Electronic Healthcare Records: A Technical Note

Harnessing Large Language Models in Medical Research and Scientific Writing: A Closer Look to The Future

Large language models in healthcare and medical domain: A review

Integrating UMLS Knowledge into Large Language Models for Medical Question Answering

A Benchmark for Long-Form Medical Question Answering

Testing and Evaluation of Health Care Applications of Large Language Models: A Systematic Review

Large language models in medical and healthcare fields: applications, advances, and challenges

A Survey on Large Language Models from General Purpose to Medical Applications: Datasets, Methodologies, and Evaluations

Large language models in medicine: the potentials and pitfalls

Dynamic Q&A of Clinical Documents with Large Language Models

An Automatic Evaluation Framework for Multi-turn Medical Consultations Capabilities of Large Language Models

A Comprehensive Survey on Evaluating Large Language Model Applications in the Medical Industry