Schur-positivity for generalized nets

Ethan Shelburne,Stephanie van Willigenburg

2024-09-02

Abstract:A graph is Schur-positive if its chromatic symmetric function expands nonnegatively in the Schur basis. All claw-free graphs are conjectured to be Schur-positive. We introduce a combinatorial object corresponding to a graph G, called a special rim hook G-tabloid, which is a variation on the special rim hook tabloid. These objects can be employed to compute any Schur coefficient of the chromatic symmetric function of a graph. We construct sign-reversing maps on these special rim hook G-tabloids to obtain a recurrence relation for the Schur coefficients of a family of claw-free graphs called generalized nets, then we prove the entire family is Schur-positive. We subsequently determine an analogous recurrence relation for another, similar family of claw-free graphs. Thus, we demonstrate a new method for proving Schur-positivity of chromatic symmetric functions, which has the potential to be applied to make further progress toward the aforementioned conjecture.

Combinatorics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to prove whether the chromatic symmetric functions of a specific class of claw - free graphs - generalized nets - are Schur - positive. Specifically, by introducing a new combinatorial object - special rim hook G - tabloids - and constructing sign - reversing maps on them, the paper obtains the recurrence relations of the Schur coefficients of generalized nets and proves that this class of graphs is indeed Schur - positive. In addition, the paper extends this method and proves that another similar class of claw - free graphs is also Schur - positive. These results provide new methods and progress for proving the Claw - free Conjecture.

### Background of the paper
1. **Chromatic symmetric function**: In 1995, Richard Stanley introduced the concept of chromatic symmetric function, which extends the normal coloring count of graphs into the symmetric function algebra. If all the coefficients in the expansion of a chromatic symmetric function under the Schur basis are non - negative, then the function is called Schur - positive.
2. **Claw - free Conjecture**: The chromatic symmetric functions of all claw - free graphs are Schur - positive. This is an important unsolved problem.
3. **Existing results**: Vesselin Gasharov has proved that all claw - free incomparability graphs are Schur - positive, but the Schur - positivity of general claw - free graphs has not been fully proved yet.

### Main contributions
1. **Introduction of new combinatorial object**: The paper introduces special rim hook G - tabloids, which is a new combinatorial object and can be used to calculate the Schur coefficients of the chromatic symmetric function of graphs.
2. **Sign - reversing map**: By constructing sign - reversing maps on these special rim hook G - tabloids, the paper obtains the recurrence relations of the Schur coefficients of generalized nets.
3. **Proof of Schur - positivity**: Using the above - mentioned methods, the paper proves that all generalized nets are Schur - positive, thus providing new progress for the proof of the Claw - free Conjecture.
4. **Extension of results**: The paper also applies these methods to another similar class of claw - free graphs and proves that they are also Schur - positive.

### Technical details
1. **Special rim hook G - tabloids**: This is a special tabloid in which each rim must intersect the first column and satisfy certain partial order relations.
2. **Sign - reversing map**: By constructing sign - reversing maps on these tabloids, the signs of certain tabloids can be eliminated, thus simplifying the calculation.
3. **Recurrence relations**: Through the above - mentioned methods, the paper obtains the recurrence relations of the Schur coefficients of generalized nets, and these relations are helpful for further studying the Schur - positivity of other types of graphs.

### Conclusion
By introducing new combinatorial tools and methods, the paper successfully proves that the chromatic symmetric functions of a specific class of claw - free graphs - generalized nets - are Schur - positive. This provides important progress and new ideas for finally proving the Claw - free Conjecture.