Online Advertising is a Regrettable Necessity: On the Dangers of Pay-Walling the Web

Yonas Kassa

2024-09-05

Abstract:The exponential growth of the web and its benefits can be attributed largely to its open model where anyone with internet connection can access information on the web for free. This has created unprecedented opportunities for various members of society including the most vulnerable, as recognized by organizations such as the UN. This again can be attributed to online advertising, which has been the main financier to the open web. However, recent trends of paywalling information and services on the web are creating imminent dangers to such open model of the web, inhibiting access for the economically vulnerable, and eventually creating digital segregation. In this paper, we argue that this emerging model lacks sustainability, exacerbates digital divide, and might lead to collapse of online advertising. We revisit the ad-supported open web business model and demonstrate how global users actually pay for the ads they see. Using data on GNI (gross national income) per capita and average paywall access costs, we established a simple income-paywall expenditure gap baseline. With this baseline we show that 135 countries with a total population estimate of 6.56 billion people cannot afford a scenario of a fully paywalled web. We further discuss how a mixed model of the so-called "premium services" creates digital segregation and poses danger to online advertising ecosystem. Finally, we call for further research and policy initiatives to keep the web open and more inclusive with a sustainable business model.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the threat posed by the paywall trend of Internet content and services to the sustainability and inclusiveness of the open - network model. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Advantages of the open - network model**:
- The paper points out that the open model of the Internet allows anyone to access information for free through an Internet connection, and this model has brought unprecedented opportunities to all members of society, especially the most vulnerable groups.
- The open network relies on online advertising as the main source of funding, enabling global users to obtain a large amount of information and online services for free.

2. **The trend of paywalls and its impacts**:
- In recent years, more and more content and services have begun to adopt the paywall model, which limits the ability of economically vulnerable people to access information and leads to the intensification of the digital divide.
- By analyzing the per - capita gross national income (GNI per capita) and the average paywall access cost in countries around the world, the author has established the Income - Paywall Expenditure Gap (IPEG) baseline. The results show that 6.56 billion people in 135 countries cannot afford a fully paywalled Internet environment.

3. **Negative impacts of the hybrid model**:
- Although the hybrid model (such as the "premium services" provided by some platforms) provides an ad - free experience or services with fewer advertisements, this model may lead to the situation where the rich can avoid watching advertisements and obtain higher - quality information and services while others are excluded, thus intensifying digital isolation.
- In the long run, this model may reduce the capitalization of the online advertising market, affect advertisers' investment intentions, and ultimately damage the entire online advertising ecosystem.

4. **Calls for research and policy support**:
- The author calls for further research and policy initiatives to maintain the openness and inclusiveness of the Internet and establish a sustainable business model.
- It is emphasized that the online advertising system needs to be improved to make it more transparent, respect user privacy, and ensure that all users can access information fairly.

### Formula summary

To illustrate that users actually pay for the advertisements they see, the following formulas are used in the paper:

\[
C_{ps}=R - C_a\tag{1}
\]

where:
- \(R\) is the total revenue of company X (i.e., the total sales of products and services)
- \(C_a\) is the expenditure of company X on online advertising
- \(C_{ps}\) is the target cost of the company after deducting advertising costs

The total cost \(TC\) can be expressed as:

\[
TC = C_{ps}+C_a\tag{2}
\]

For each user and each item, the total cost \(TC\) can be further expanded as:

\[
TC=\sum_{i\in items}\sum_{j\in users}(C_{ps}(i)(j)+C_a(i)(j))\tag{3}
\]

The Income - Paywall Expenditure Gap (IPEG) is defined as:

\[
IPEG = GNI_{pc}-PWAC\tag{4}
\]

where:
- \(GNI_{pc}\) is the per - capita gross national income
- \(PWAC\) is the paywall access cost

These formulas help to quantify the impact of paywalls on the economic burden of users and reveal their unsustainability.