SoK: Identifying Limitations and Bridging Gaps of Cybersecurity Capability Maturity Models (CCMMs)

Lasini Liyanage,Nalin Asanka Gamagedara Arachchilage,Giovanni Russello

2024-08-29

Abstract:In the rapidly evolving digital landscape, where organisations are increasingly vulnerable to cybersecurity threats, Cybersecurity Capability Maturity Models (CCMMs) emerge as pivotal tools in enhancing organisational cybersecurity posture. CCMMs provide a structured framework to guide organisations in assessing their current cybersecurity capabilities, identifying critical gaps, and prioritising improvements. However, the full potential of CCMMs is often not realised due to inherent limitations within the models and challenges encountered during their implementation and adoption processes. These limitations and challenges can significantly hamper the efficacy of CCMMs in improving cybersecurity. As a result, organisations remain vulnerable to cyber threats as they may fail to identify and address critical security gaps, implement necessary improvements or allocate resources effectively. To address these limitations and challenges, conducting a thorough investigation into existing models is essential. Therefore, we conducted a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) analysing 43 publications to identify existing CCMMs, their limitations, and the challenges organisations face when implementing and adopting them. By understanding these barriers, we aim to explore avenues for enhancing the efficacy of CCMMs, ensuring they more effectively meet the cybersecurity needs of organisational entities.

Cryptography and Security

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: **Identify the limitations of existing Cybersecurity Capability Maturity Models (CCMMs) and bridge the gaps encountered in the implementation and adoption processes of these models in different organizational and industrial contexts**.

Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Limitations of CCMMs**:
- Existing CCMMs often fail to fully consider the unique backgrounds and operational dynamics of different organizations, resulting in difficulties in effective customization and implementation.
- The complexity of the models, the lack of clear implementation guidelines, and the inconsistency with organizational priorities further exacerbate these problems.
- Many CCMMs overlook key factors such as organizational culture and resource limitations, leading to resistance and sub - optimal adoption effects.

2. **Challenges in implementing and adopting CCMMs**:
- Organizations face deficiencies in technical, policy, procedural safeguards, and educational interventions when implementing and adopting CCMMs.
- The diversity in different industrial sectors and organizational environments increases the difficulty of a unified cybersecurity strategy.
- Small and medium - sized enterprises (SMEs) usually lack the resources and expertise required to effectively implement a comprehensive CCMM, while large enterprises may encounter difficulties in integrating these models in complex multi - level structures.

3. **The need to improve the effectiveness of CCMMs**:
- In order to better protect organizational assets, maintain stakeholder trust, and improve overall cybersecurity resilience, it is necessary to enhance the adaptability, practicality, and alignment with specific needs and constraints of CCMMs.
- Through a Systematic Literature Review (SLR), identify the limitations and challenges of existing CCMMs and propose improvement suggestions based on empirical evidence to meet the specific needs of different organizations.

In summary, the paper aims to provide a scientific basis for improving these models by systematically reviewing existing literature, identifying the limitations and implementation challenges of CCMMs, thereby ensuring that they can more effectively respond to ever - changing cyber threats.