Abstract:We study the quasinormal modes of the spherically-symmetric $(2+1)$-dimensional analogue black hole, modeled by the ``draining bathtub'' fluid flow, and the $(3+1)$-dimensional canonical acoustic black hole. In the both cases the emphasis is on the accuracy. Formally, the radial equation describing perturbations of the $(2+1)$-dimensional black hole is a special case of the general master equation of the 5-dimensional Tangherlini black hole. Similarly, the $(3+1)$-dimensional equation can be obtained from the master equation of the 7-dimensional Tangherlini black hole. For the $(2+1)$-dimensional analogue black hole we used three major techniques: the higher-order WKB method with the Padé summation, the Hill-determinant method and the continued fraction method, the latter two with the convergence acceleration. In the $(3+1)$-dimensional case, we propose the simpler recurrence relations and explicitly demonstrate that both recurrences, i.e., the eight-term and the six-term recurrences yield identical results. Since the application of the continued-fraction method require five (or three) consecutive Gauss eliminations, we decided not to use this technique in the $(3+1)$-dimensional case. Instead, we used the Hill-determinant method in the two incarnations and the higher-order WKB. We accept the results of our calculations if at least two (algorithmically) independent methods give the same answer to some prescribed accuracy. Our results correct and extend the results existing in the literature and we believe that we approached assumed accuracy of 9 decimal places. In most cases, there is perfect agreement between all the methods; however, in a few cases, the performance of the higher-order WKB method is slightly worse.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to accurately calculate the quasinormal modes (QNMs) analogous to black holes. Specifically, the author has studied the quasinormal modes of two - dimensional (2 + 1 - dimensional) and three - dimensional (3 + 1 - dimensional) analog black holes, and has particularly emphasized the accuracy of the calculation. Analog black holes are systems that can simulate the physical phenomena of real black holes under laboratory conditions, for example, by using hydrodynamic models to simulate the propagation behavior of sound waves near black holes.
### Main Research Contents
1. **Model Description**:
- **Two - Dimensional Analog Black Hole**: Use the "draining bathtub" model to describe the (2 + 1 - dimensional) analog black hole, where the velocity and speed of sound of the background fluid determine the properties of the black hole.
- **Three - Dimensional Analog Black Hole**: Use the classical acoustic black hole model to describe the (3 + 1 - dimensional) analog black hole, which is based on the spherically symmetric flow of an incompressible, non - viscous, adiabatic fluid.
2. **Radial Equation**:
- The author points out that the radial equation of the two - dimensional analog black hole can be regarded as a special case of the five - dimensional Tangherlini black hole master equation.
- The radial equation of the three - dimensional analog black hole can be regarded as a special case of the seven - dimensional Tangherlini black hole master equation.
3. **Calculation Method**:
- **High - Order WKB Method**: Combined with the Padé summation technique, it is used to calculate the frequencies of quasinormal modes.
- **Hill Determinant Method**: Determine the frequencies of quasinormal modes by solving the determinant equation.
- **Continued Fraction Method**: Used to verify the results of other methods and improve the calculation accuracy.
- **Recurrence Relation**: Proposed eight - term and six - term recurrence relations to simplify the calculation process.
4. **Result Verification**:
- The author requires that at least two independent methods give the same result within a predetermined accuracy, usually 9 decimal places.
- For low - frequency modes and their overtones, the author has carried out detailed calculations and compared them with the results in the existing literature. It is found that in most cases the results are consistent, but in some cases the performance of the high - order WKB method is slightly worse.
### Research Significance
- **Theoretical Contribution**: Provide highly accurate quasinormal mode frequencies, correct and extend the results in the existing literature.
- **Experimental Application**: Provide theoretical support for analog black hole experiments under laboratory conditions, which is helpful for extracting information of quasinormal modes from experimental data.
- **Method Improvement**: By comparing and verifying different calculation methods, show the advantages and limitations of various methods, providing references for future research.
In conclusion, this paper has studied in detail the quasinormal modes of analog black holes through a variety of high - precision calculation methods, providing an important theoretical basis for understanding black hole physics and laboratory simulations.