Blackbox optimization for origami-inspired bistable structures

Luca Boisneault,Charles Audet,David Melancon

2024-08-27

Abstract:Bistable mechanical systems exhibit two stable configurations where the elastic energy is locally minimized. To realize such systems, origami techniques have been proposed as a versatile platform to design deployable structures with both compact and functional stable states. Conceptually, a bistable origami motif is composed of two-dimensional surfaces connected by one-dimensional fold lines. This leads to stable configurations exhibiting zero-energy local minima. Physically, origami-inspired structures are three-dimensional, comprising facets and hinges fabricated in a distinct stable state where residual stresses are minimized. This leads to the dominance of one stable state over the other. To improve mechanical performance, one can solve the constrained optimization problem of maximizing the bistability of origami structures, defined as the amount of elastic energy required to switch between stable states, while ensuring materials used for the facets and hinges remain within their elastic regime. In this study, the Mesh Adaptive Direct Search (MADS) algorithm, a blackbox optimization technique, is used to solve the constrained optimization problem. The bistable waterbomb-base origami motif is selected as a case-study to present the methodology. The elastic energy of this origami pattern under deployment is calculated via Finite Element simulations which serve as the blackbox in the MADS optimization loop. To validate the results, optimized waterbomb-base geometries are built via Fused Filament Fabrication and their response under loading is characterized experimentally on a Uniaxial Test Machine. Ultimately, our method offers a general framework for optimizing bistability in mechanical systems, presenting opportunities for advancement across various engineering applications.

Optimization and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to optimize the mechanical properties of origami - inspired bistable structures. Specifically, the author aims to maximize the elastic energy required for such structures to switch between two stable states by optimizing design parameters, while ensuring that the material remains within its elastic range and taking manufacturing limitations into account.

### Problem Background

Bistable mechanical systems have two stable configurations in which the elastic energy is locally minimized. To realize such systems, origami techniques have been proposed as a versatile platform for designing deployable structures with compact and functionally stable states. However, existing research has mainly focused on characterizing the influence of geometry on multistability, with less attention paid to how to improve bistable performance by optimizing design parameters.

### Research Objectives

The main objective of this paper is to develop a general framework for optimizing the bistable performance of origami - inspired structures. Specifically, the author has chosen the waterbomb base as a case study, which is a simple bistable structure. By using the finite element method (FEM) to simulate its elastic energy change and combining it with a black - box optimization algorithm (such as the MADS algorithm), the author hopes to find the best combination of design parameters to maximize the energy required to return from the second stable state to the first stable state.

### Solutions

1. **Modeling and Simulation**:
- Use the finite element method (FEM) to simulate the elastic energy change of the waterbomb base.
- Parameterize geometric parameters (such as angles, thickness ratios, etc.) and calculate the bistable performance under different parameter combinations through FEM.

2. **Optimization Algorithm**:
- Use the Mesh Adaptive Direct Search (MADS) algorithm, which is a derivative - free constrained black - box optimization technique.
- The optimization objective is to maximize the energy required to return from the second stable state to the first stable state ($\phi=\frac{\Delta U}{U_{\text{max}}}$), while ensuring that the maximum stress does not exceed the yield strength of the material ($\sigma_{\text{max}}\leq S_Y$).

3. **Experimental Verification**:
- Manufacture physical prototypes by the Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) method and conduct experimental verification on a uniaxial testing machine.
- Compare the experimental results with the FEM simulation results to evaluate the accuracy of the model.

### Results and Impact

Through optimization, the author has found a combination of design parameters that can significantly improve bistable performance. For example, considering manufacturing limitations, the optimized geometric parameters have increased the bistable performance from 28.85% in the initial design to 64.8%, almost doubling it. In addition, the author has also explored the impact of high - resolution manufacturing techniques on the optimization results and proposed a method of adding elastic energy constraints during the optimization process to ensure that the structure can store sufficient elastic energy during load application.

In summary, this research provides a general framework that can be used to optimize bistable mechanical systems in various engineering applications, providing an important reference for future research and practical applications.