Abstract:Effective ownership of software artifacts, particularly code, is crucial for accountability, knowledge sharing, and code quality enhancement. Researchers have proposed models linking ownership of software artifacts with developer performance and code quality. Our study aims to systematically examine various ownership models and provide a structured literature overview. Conducting a systematic literature review, we identified 79 relevant papers published between 2005 and 2022. We developed a taxonomy of ownership artifacts based on type, owners, and degree of ownership, along with compiling modeling variables and analytics types used in each study. Additionally, we assessed the replication status of each study. As a result, we identified nine distinct software artifacts whose ownership has been discussed in the literature, with "Code" being the most frequently analyzed artifact. We found that only three papers (3.79%) provided code and data, whereas nine papers (11.4%) provided only data. Using our systematic literature review results, we replicated experiments on nine priority projects at Brightsquid . The company aimed to compare its code quality against ownership factors in other teams, so we conducted a replication study using their data. Unlike prior studies, we found no strong correlation between minor contributors and bug numbers. Surprisingly, we found no strong link between the total number of developers modifying a file and bug counts, contrasting previous findings. However, we observed a significant correlation between major contributors and bug counts, diverging from earlier research. This study provides a comprehensive overview of ownership models and lists the variables used for ownership modeling in software engineering. Additionally, the study's findings can inform the development of best practices for software development teams and assist in decision-making, considering various company and project contexts.

Code Ownership: The Principles, Differences, and Their Associations with Software Quality

Examining ownership models in software teams

Examining Ownership Models in Software Teams: A Systematic Literature Review and a Replication Study

U Owns the Code That Changes and How Marginal Owners Resolve Issues Slower in Low-Quality Source Code

Code Ownership in Open-Source AI Software Security

Exploring the Relationship Between Ownership and Contribution Alignment and Code Technical Debt

Governing the Commons: Code Ownership and Code-Clones in Large-Scale Software Development

The impact of software complexity on cost and quality - A comparative analysis between Open source and proprietary software

Code Red: The Business Impact of Code Quality -- A Quantitative Study of 39 Proprietary Production Codebases

Revisiting Linus's Law: Benefits and Challenges of Open Source Software Peer Review.

Why is My Code Change Abandoned?

Communication and Code Dependency Effects on Software Code Quality: An Empirical Analysis of Herbsleb Hypothesis

Increasing, not Diminishing: Investigating the Returns of Highly Maintainable Code

Ownership in the Hands of Accountability at Brightsquid -- A Case Study and a Developer Survey

Ownership at Large -- Open Problems and Challenges in Ownership Management

To What Extent Can Code Quality be Improved by Eliminating Test Smells?

Who Made This Copy? An Empirical Analysis of Code Clone Authorship

Challenges in Comparing Code Maintainability across Different Programming Languages

Code quality analysis in open source software development

Do We Need Improved Code Quality Metrics?

Broken Windows: Exploring the Applicability of a Controversial Theory on Code Quality