The Unique Citing Documents Journal Impact Factor (Uniq-JIF) as a Supplement for the standard Journal Impact Factor

Zhesi Shen,Li Li,Yu Liao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jdis-2024-0024

2024-08-05

Abstract:This paper introduces the Unique Citing Documents Journal Impact Factor(Uniq-JIF) as a supplement to the traditional Journal Impact Factor(JIF). The Uniq-JIF counts each citing document only once, aiming to reduce the effects of citation manipulations. Analysis of 2023 Journal Citation Reports data shows that for most journals, the Uniq-JIF is less than 20% lower than the JIF, though some journals show a drop of over 75%. The Uniq-JIF also highlights significant reductions for journals suppressed due to citation issues, indicating its effectiveness in identifying problematic journals. The Uniq-JIF offers a more nuanced view of a journal's influence and can help reveal journals needing further scrutiny.

Digital Libraries

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the shortcomings of the existing Journal Impact Factor (JIF) in evaluating the influence of journals. Specifically, the traditional JIF is susceptible to abnormal citation behaviors such as citation manipulation, coercive self-citation, and citation stacking, which can artificially inflate the JIF of certain journals. To mitigate the impact of these abnormal citation behaviors on the JIF, the authors propose a new impact factor—the Unique Citing Documents Journal Impact Factor (Uniq-JIF).

The definition of Uniq-JIF is as follows:
\[ \text{Uniq-JIF} = \frac{\text{Number of unique citing documents}}{\text{Number of citable items}} \]

Unlike the traditional JIF, Uniq-JIF only counts the number of unique citing documents that cite articles from a particular journal, rather than the total number of citations. This calculation method can more accurately reflect the journal's influence in the academic community, avoiding the distortion of metrics caused by abnormal citation behaviors.

By analyzing the data from the 2023 Journal Citation Reports, the authors calculated the Uniq-JIF for all SCI, SSCI, and ESCI indexed journals and compared it with the traditional JIF. The results showed that for most journals, the Uniq-JIF decreased by less than 20% compared to the JIF, but for 13 journals, the Uniq-JIF decreased by more than 75%. Particularly, journals that were suppressed due to citation-related issues saw a more significant decrease in their Uniq-JIF, indicating that Uniq-JIF may help reveal potentially problematic journals.

In summary, this paper introduces Uniq-JIF as a new impact factor, aiming to provide a supplementary perspective to help more accurately assess the academic influence of journals and identify journals that may have citation issues.