Multilayer Network of Cardiovascular Diseases and Depression via Multipartite Projection

Jie Li,Cillian Hourican,Pashupati P. Mishra,Binisha H. Mishra,Mika Kähönen,Olli T. Raitakari,Reijo Laaksonen,Mika Ala-Korpela,Liisa Keltikangas-Järvinen,Markus Juonala,Terho Lehtimäki,Jos A. Bosch,Rick Quax
2024-08-26
Abstract:Cardiovascular diseases (CVD) and depression exhibit significant comorbidity, which is highly predictive of poor clinical outcomes. Yet, the underlying biological pathways remain challenging to decipher, presumably due to the non-linear associations across multiple mechanisms. In this study, we introduced a multipartite projection method based on mutual information correlations to construct multilayer disease networks as a novel approach to explore such intricate relationships. We applied this method to a cross-sectional dataset from a wave of the Young Finns Study, which includes data on CVD and depression, along with related risk factors and two omics of biomarkers: metabolites and lipids. Rather than directly correlating CVD-related phenotypes and depressive symptoms, we extended the notion of bipartite networks to create a multipartite network, linking these phenotypes and symptoms to intermediate biological variables. Projecting from these intermediate variables results in a weighted multilayer network, where each link between CVD and depression variables is marked by its layer (i.e., metabolome or lipidome). Applying this projection method, we identified potential mediating biomarkers that connect CVD with depression. These biomarkers may therefore play significant roles in the biological pathways underlying CVD-depression comorbidity. Additionally, the network projection highlighted sex and BMI as key risk factors, or confounders, in this comorbidity. Our method is scalable to incorporate any number of omics layers and various disease phenotypes, offering a comprehensive, system-level perspective on the biological pathways contributing to comorbidity.
Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the complex comorbidity relationship between cardiovascular disease (CVD) and depression. Specifically, the authors aim to construct a multi - layer disease network based on mutual - information correlation by introducing a new multi - part projection method, in order to reveal the underlying biological mechanisms and key biomarkers between these two diseases. ### Research Background and Problems Cardiovascular disease (CVD) and depression are major global health challenges, and there is a significant comorbidity between them, which can greatly increase the risk of adverse clinical outcomes. Although previous studies have shown that behavioral and biological factors play a role in the bidirectional relationship between them, the specific nature of these interactions has not been fully elucidated. Existing research methods have certain limitations in explaining this complex non - linear association: 1. **Single - layer omics data**: Most studies use only a single omics data (such as genes), ignoring data at other levels (such as proteins, lipids, etc.). 2. **Simple counting method**: Directly count the shared intermediate biomarkers, ignoring the strength of their correlation. 3. **Linear correlation**: Use the Pearson correlation coefficient and cannot capture non - linear correlations. 4. **Lack of high - order correlation**: Fail to incorporate high - order correlations into the analysis. ### Solutions To solve the above problems, the authors propose a new multi - part projection method, which has the following characteristics: - **Multi - omics data integration**: It can integrate any number of omics data sets and multiple disease phenotypes. - **Non - parametric mutual - information (MI) correlation**: Use Shannon mutual - information to capture linear and non - linear dependencies between variables. - **Weighted counting method**: Weight the shared intermediate biomarkers to provide more detailed quantification of the association. ### Method Application The authors applied this method to a cross - sectional data set of the Young Finns Study (YFS), which includes relevant phenotypes of CVD and depression, risk factors, and biomarkers of the metabolome and lipidome. Through this method, the authors identified key biomarkers connecting CVD and depression, such as creatinine, valine, phospholipids, triglycerides, etc., and found that gender and BMI are important risk factors. ### Main Findings - **Key biomarkers**: Multiple metabolites and lipids were identified as potential intermediate biomarkers, such as creatinine, valine, phospholipids, triglycerides, etc. - **Risk factors**: Gender and BMI were confirmed as risk factors closely related to the comorbidity of CVD and depression. - **Network structure**: A weighted multi - layer network was constructed, showing the complex association between CVD and depression, providing a system - level perspective. ### Conclusions By introducing the multi - part projection method, this study not only reveals the underlying biological mechanisms between CVD and depression, but also provides a comprehensive system - level framework, which is helpful for future research to further understand complex disease interactions. This method can better explain the biological pathways behind the comorbidity phenomenon and provides new ideas for clinical treatment and prevention. ### Formula Summary Mutual - information (MI) calculation formula: \[ MI(X;Y) = \sum_{y \in Y} \sum_{x \in X} p(x,y) \cdot \log \frac{p(x,y)}{p(x)p(y)} \] Projection score calculation formula: \[ w(X_i;X_j) = \sum_k \frac{f(X_i;Y_k) + f(X_j;Y_k)}{2} \] Contribution score calculation formula: \[ CON(Y_k) = \sum_{i,j} \frac{f(X_i;Y_k) + f(X_j;Y_k)}{2} \] Risk factor relative importance calculation formula: \[ r(Z_i,X_j) = \frac{w(Z_i;X_j)}{\sum_i w(Z_i;X_j)} \] These formulas ensure the accurate quantification and interpretation of complex disease associations.