Harmonic Stability Analysis of Microgrids with Converter-Interfaced Distributed Energy Resources, Part II: Case Studies

Johanna Kristin Maria Becker,Andreas Martin Kettner,Mario Paolone

2024-08-12

Abstract:In Part I of this paper a method for the Harmonic Stability Assessment (HSA) of power systems with a high share of Converter-Interfaced Distributed Energy Resources (CIDERs) was proposed. Specifically, the Harmonic State-Space (HSS) model of a generic power system is derived through combination of the components HSS models. The HSS models of CIDERs and grid are based on Linear Time-Periodic (LTP) models, capable of representing the coupling between different harmonics. In Part II, the HSA of a grid-forming, and two grid-following CIDERs (i.e., ex- and including the DC-side modelling) is performed. More precisely, the classification of the eigenvalues, the impact of the maximum harmonic order on the locations of the eigenvalues, and the sensitivity curves of the eigenvalues w.r.t. to control parameters are provided. These analyses allow to study the physical meaning and origin of the CIDERs eigenvalues. Additionally, the HSA is performed for a representative example system derived from the CIGRE low-voltage benchmark system. A case of harmonic instability is identified through the system eigenvalues, and validated with Time-Domain Simulations (TDS) in Simulink. It is demonstrated that, as opposed to stability analyses based on Linear Time-Invariant (LTI) models, the HSA is suitable for the detection of harmonic instability.

Systems and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper attempts to solve the harmonic stability assessment (HSA) problem of power systems containing a large number of converter - interface - based distributed energy resources (CIDERs). Specifically, the paper proposes a method for evaluating the harmonic stability of power systems with a high proportion of CIDERs and verifies the effectiveness of this method through case studies.

### Detailed Explanation

1. **Background and Motivation**:
- With the wide use of renewable energy and distributed energy, converter - interface - based distributed energy resources (CIDERs) are increasingly adopted in power systems. The introduction of these resources brings new challenges, especially in terms of harmonic stability.
- Traditional linear time - invariant (LTI) models have limitations in evaluating harmonic stability because they cannot capture the coupling effects between different harmonics.

2. **Proposed Method**:
- The paper proposes a method based on the harmonic state - space (HSS) model to evaluate the harmonic stability of power systems. The HSS model constructs the HSS model of the entire system by combining the HSS models of individual components.
- The HSS model is based on the linear time - periodic (LTP) model and can represent the coupling relationships between different harmonics.

3. **Case Studies**:
- In the second part, the paper verifies the effectiveness of the proposed method by conducting harmonic stability analysis on three CIDERs (i.e., the grid - forming CIDER and two grid - following CIDERs).
- The specific analysis includes eigenvalue classification, the influence of the maximum harmonic order on the eigenvalue position, and the sensitivity curves of eigenvalues to control parameters.

4. **Representative System Analysis**:
- The paper also conducts a harmonic stability assessment on a representative example system derived from the CIGRÉ low - voltage benchmark system.
- A case of harmonic instability is identified through system eigenvalues and verified by time - domain simulation (TDS) in Simulink.
- The results show that compared with the stability analysis based on the LTI model, HSA is more suitable for detecting harmonic instability.

### Main Contributions

- **Method Innovation**: A harmonic stability assessment method based on the HSS model is proposed, which can more accurately capture the coupling effects between different harmonics.
- **Theoretical Verification**: The effectiveness of the proposed method is verified through detailed eigenvalue analysis and sensitivity analysis.
- **Practical Application**: Through a case study of an actual power system, the application value of this method in actual engineering is demonstrated.

### Formula Examples

- **Eigenvalue Distance Metric**:
\[
d_i(h_{\text{max}})=\| \lambda_i^{\text{LTI}}-\lambda_i^{\text{LTP}}(h_{\text{max}}) \|_1
\]
\[
d(h_{\text{max}})=\max_i (d_i(h_{\text{max}}))
\]

- **Eigenvalue Classification**:
- **Control Design Invariant (CDI)**: Eigenvalues are insensitive to changes in control parameters.
- **Control Design Variant (CDV)**: Eigenvalues are sensitive to changes in control parameters.
- **Design Invariant (DI)**: Eigenvalues are insensitive to all parameter changes.

### Conclusion

By proposing a harmonic stability assessment method based on the HSS model, this paper successfully solves the harmonic stability problem in power systems containing a large number of CIDERs. Through detailed case studies and theoretical analysis, the effectiveness and practicality of this method are proved.