Abstract:Threshold-driven models and game theory are two fundamental paradigms for describing human interactions in social systems. However, in mimicking social contagion processes, models that simultaneously incorporate these two mechanisms have been largely overlooked. Here, we study a general model that integrates hybrid interaction forms by assuming that a part of nodes in a network are driven by the threshold mechanism, while the remaining nodes exhibit imitation behavior governed by their rationality (under the game-theoretic framework). Our results reveal that the spreading dynamics are determined by the payoff of adoption. For positive payoffs, increasing the density of highly rational nodes can promote the adoption process, accompanied by a double phase transition. The degree of rationality can regulate the spreading speed, with less rational imitators slowing down the spread. We further find that the results are opposite for negative payoffs of adoption. This model may provide valuable insights into understanding the complex dynamics of social contagion phenomena in real-world social networks.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in the existing social contagion models, there is a relative lack of research on simultaneously combining the two forms of interaction: the threshold - driven mechanism and the game - theory - based imitative behavior. Specifically:
1. **Threshold - driven models**: These models assume that the state of a node is affected by the states of its neighbors. When the proportion of neighbors that have adopted a certain behavior exceeds a certain threshold, the node will change its state.
2. **Game - theory - based imitative behavior**: These models assume that individuals are rational and decide whether to imitate others' behaviors according to the payoff.
However, in actual social networks, these two mechanisms often work together, but currently there is a lack of a unified model that can comprehensively consider these two mechanisms. Therefore, this paper proposes a new hybrid interaction model, aiming to fill this research gap.
### Model overview
In this model, the nodes in the network are divided into two types:
- **Type - 0 nodes**: These nodes follow the threshold - driven mechanism and will change their state only when the proportion of adopters among their neighbors exceeds a given threshold \(\phi\).
- **Type - 1 nodes**: These nodes make decisions based on game theory and decide whether to adopt new behaviors according to the interaction payoffs with their neighbors.
### Key issues
The paper explores the following key issues through this model:
- **The relationship between spreading dynamics and payoff**: Research shows that the spreading dynamics are mainly determined by the payoff of the adoption behavior. For positive payoffs, increasing the proportion of rational nodes can promote the adoption process; while for negative payoffs, the opposite is true.
- **The influence of the degree of rationality on the spreading speed**: The degree of rationality of nodes can regulate the spreading speed, and less rational imitators will slow down the spreading speed.
- **The biphasic transition phenomenon**: For positive payoff situations, increasing the density of rational nodes can trigger biphasic transitions, while in the negative payoff situation, the opposite is true.
### Conclusion
This model provides valuable insights for understanding the complex contagion phenomena in real - world social networks, especially in terms of how to integrate the threshold - driven mechanism and the game - theory - based imitative behavior. This helps to more comprehensively explain the formation and development of collective behaviors in social systems.
### Formula summary
- The formula for the adoption rate driven by the threshold:
\[
F_{k_i,0} =
\begin{cases}
1 & \text{if } m_i \geq k_i \phi \\
0 & \text{otherwise}
\end{cases}
\]
- The formula for the imitation probability based on game theory (Fermi function):
\[
\theta_{i \to j} = \frac{1}{1 + e^{-\beta (\Gamma_j - \Gamma_i)}}
\]
- The adoption rate formula:
\[
F_{k_i,1} = \theta \frac{m_i}{k_i}
\]
Through these formulas, the paper shows the dynamic characteristics of the social contagion process under different parameter settings.