Natural Language Outlines for Code: Literate Programming in the LLM Era

Kensen Shi,Deniz Altınbüken,Saswat Anand,Mihai Christodorescu,Katja Grünwedel,Alexa Koenings,Sai Naidu,Anurag Pathak,Marc Rasi,Fredde Ribeiro,Brandon Ruffin,Siddhant Sanyam,Maxim Tabachnyk,Sara Toth,Roy Tu,Tobias Welp,Pengcheng Yin,Manzil Zaheer,Satish Chandra,Charles Sutton
2024-08-09
Abstract:We propose using natural language outlines as a novel modality and interaction surface for providing AI assistance to developers throughout the software development process. An NL outline for a code function comprises multiple statements written in concise prose, which partition the code and summarize its main ideas in the style of literate programming. Crucially, we find that modern LLMs can generate accurate and high-quality NL outlines in practice. Moreover, NL outlines enable a bidirectional sync between code and NL, allowing changes in one to be automatically reflected in the other. We discuss many use cases for NL outlines: they can accelerate understanding and navigation of code and diffs, simplify code maintenance, augment code search, steer code generation, and more. We then propose and compare multiple LLM prompting techniques for generating outlines and ask professional developers to judge outline quality. Finally, we present two case studies applying NL outlines toward code review and the difficult task of malware detection.
Software Engineering,Artificial Intelligence,Human-Computer Interaction,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of how to utilize Natural Language (NL) outlines to enhance developers' efficiency and code comprehension during the software development process. Specifically, the paper proposes using NL outlines as a novel interactive interface to tackle the challenges developers face in understanding and maintaining code through the following ways: 1. **Accelerating Code Understanding and Navigation**: NL outlines can provide a high-level overview of the code, helping developers quickly grasp the main logic without reading the code line by line. Additionally, the outline can be displayed alongside the code, offering intuitive code folding functionality for easier browsing and navigation. 2. **Simplifying Code Maintenance**: When developers modify the code or the outline, they can automatically synchronize updates to the other side using Large Language Models (LLMs), ensuring consistency between documentation and code, and reducing the tedious task of manually updating documentation. 3. **Enhancing Code Search**: NL outlines can complement code search, allowing developers to find specific functions or code snippets through natural language queries, thereby improving the intuitiveness and accuracy of the search. 4. **Guiding Code Generation**: Developers can guide code generation by writing NL outlines, avoiding the direct generation of incorrect or unexpected code. This approach enables developers to think and design code at a higher level, improving development efficiency. 5. **Supporting Code Review**: During code reviews, NL outlines can help reviewers quickly understand the code written by others. Especially when the outline is automatically updated to reflect code changes, reviewers can better understand the changes by comparing the old and new outlines. In summary, this paper aims to introduce NL outlines, leveraging the capabilities of modern large language models, to provide developers with a new, efficient tool for code understanding and maintenance, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and quality of the software development process.