Abstract:Notch signaling is a ubiquitous and versatile intercellular signaling system that drives collective behaviors and pattern formation in biological tissues. During embryonic development, Notch is involved in generation of collective biochemical oscillations that form the vertebrate body segments, and its failure results in embryonic defects. Notch ligands of the Delta family are key components of this collective rhythm, but it is unclear how different Delta ligands with distinct properties contribute to relaying information among cells. Motivated by the zebrafish segmentation clock, in this work we propose a theory describing interactions between biochemical oscillators, where Notch receptor is bound by both oscillatory and nonoscillatory Delta ligands. Based on previous in vitro binding studies, we first consider Notch activation by Delta dimers. This hypothesis is consistent with experimental observations in conditions of perturbed Notch signaling. Then we test an alternative hypothesis where Delta monomers directly bind and activate Notch, and show that this second model can also describe the experimental observations. We show that these two hypotheses assign different roles for a non-oscillatory ligand, as a binding partner or as a baseline signal. Finally, we discuss experiments to distinguish between the two scenarios. Broadly, this work highlights how a multiplicity of ligands may be harnessed by a signaling system to generate versatile responses.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the mechanism of the Notch signaling pathway in the segmentation clock of zebrafish, particularly how different Notch ligands (such as DeltaC and DeltaD) work together to maintain synchronized oscillations between cells, which is crucial for the correct formation of vertebrate body segments. The core research questions of the paper can be summarized as follows: 1. **Understanding the role of Delta ligands**: The Notch signaling pathway controls pattern formation during embryonic development by regulating cell behavior. Ligands of the Delta family (especially DeltaC and DeltaD) are essential for collective oscillations in the segmentation clock, but it is not entirely clear how different Delta ligands coordinate to transmit information and achieve synchronization between cells. 2. **Binding modes of Delta ligands to Notch receptors**: The study proposes two hypotheses: one is that Delta ligands bind to Notch receptors in a dimeric form; the other is that Delta ligands bind directly to Notch receptors in a monomeric form. These two hypotheses offer different explanations for the function of non-oscillatory ligands like DeltaD. 3. **Impact of different Delta ligands on synchronization**: The paper investigates the roles of different Delta ligands (DeltaC and DeltaD) and Notch receptors in maintaining or disrupting the synchronized oscillations of the segmentation clock, and analyzes how these factors affect the accuracy of segment formation during embryonic development. 4. **Theoretical model construction and validation**: Based on the above questions, the paper constructs a theoretical framework to describe the interactions between Delta ligands and receptors in the Notch signaling pathway under different scenarios. It also validates these models through simulation experiments to see if they can explain the observed experimental phenomena, including the consistency of different mutant phenotypes and the timing of segment defects under various conditions. In summary, this paper aims to deeply understand how Delta ligands in the Notch signaling pathway regulate the synchronized oscillations of the segmentation clock, particularly how they work together to maintain normal embryonic development in the presence of different Delta ligands.

Multiple Notch ligands in the synchronization of the segmentation clock

Species-specific roles of the Notch ligands, receptors, and targets orchestrating the signaling landscape of the segmentation clock

Synchronization of the segmentation clock using synthetic cell-cell signaling

Intercellular Coupling Regulates the Period of the Segmentation Clock

The Alternate Ligand Jagged Enhances the Robustness of Notch Signaling Patterns

Lateral Inhibition in Cell Specification Mediated by Mechanical Signals Modulating TAZ Activity

Mechanisms of Notch signaling: a simple logic deployed in time and space

Understanding the Principles of Pattern Formation Driven by Notch Signaling by Integrating Experiments and Theoretical Models

Mutual inactivation of Notch and Delta permits a simple mechanism for lateral inhibition patterning

Intrinsic noise, Delta-Notch signalling and delayed reactions promote sustained, coherent, synchronised oscillations in the presomitic mesoderm

Dynamic Ligand Discrimination in the Notch Signaling Pathway

A Complex Oscillating Network of Signaling Genes Underlies the Mouse Segmentation Clock

An analysis of overall network architecture reveals an infinite-period bifurcation underlying oscillation arrest in the segmentation clock

Oscillatory DeltaC Expression in Neural Progenitors Primes the Prototype of Forebrain Development

A role for actomyosin contractility in Notch signaling

Notch-Jagged signaling complex defined by an interaction mosaic

The Canonical Notch Signaling Pathway: Unfolding the Activation Mechanism

Single cell response landscape of graded Nodal signaling in zebrafish explants

Structural and functional studies of the EGF20-27 region reveal new features of the human Notch receptor important for optimal activation

Delayed coupling theory of vertebrate segmentation

Temporal dynamics and stoichiometry in human Notch signaling from Notch synaptic complex formation to nuclear entry of the Notch intracellular domain