Impacts of Anthropomorphizing Large Language Models in Learning Environments

Kristina Schaaff,Marc-André Heidelmann

2024-07-22

Abstract:Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in learning environments to support teaching-be it as learning companions or as tutors. With our contribution, we aim to discuss the implications of the anthropomorphization of LLMs in learning environments on educational theory to build a foundation for more effective learning outcomes and understand their emotional impact on learners. According to the media equation, people tend to respond to media in the same way as they would respond to another person. A study conducted by the Georgia Institute of Technology showed that chatbots can be successfully implemented in learning environments. In this study, learners in selected online courses were unable to distinguish the chatbot from a "real" teacher. As LLM-based chatbots such as OpenAI's GPT series are increasingly used in educational tools, it is important to understand how the attribution processes to LLM-based chatbots in terms of anthropomorphization affect learners' emotions.

Computation and Language,Artificial Intelligence,Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application of large language models (LLMs) in educational environments and the impact of their anthropomorphism. As large language models are increasingly used as teaching aids, such as learning partners or tutors, researchers focus on how the anthropomorphism of these models affects educational theory and, based on this, enhances learning outcomes and understands their emotional impact on learners.

The main questions posed by the paper are:
1. When large language models are presented in a human-like manner (i.e., endowed with human-like characteristics), can this anthropomorphism elicit strong emotional responses from learners, such as irritation or a sense of unfamiliarity?
2. If such emotional responses are indeed elicited, do these emotional responses significantly affect the learning outcomes when using large language models?

Researchers plan to explore the above questions by designing an experiment in which two different learning systems will be developed: one integrating anthropomorphic factors and the other without these factors. By comparing and analyzing the usage of these two systems and evaluating the emotional states of participants during the task, the study aims to investigate how anthropomorphic large language models affect learning outcomes.

In summary, this paper aims to explore the phenomenon of anthropomorphism in large language models within educational contexts and its impact on learners' emotions and learning effectiveness. By delving into these issues, researchers hope to provide guidance for educators, helping them better utilize artificial intelligence technology to improve teaching outcomes.