Abstract:The diffusion of novel information through social networks is essential for dismantling echo chambers and promoting innovation. Our study examines how two major types of viral channels, specifically Direct Messaging (DM) and Broadcasting (BC), impact the well-known "strength of weak ties" in disseminating novel information across social networks. We conducted a large-scale empirical analysis, examining the sharing behavior of 500,000 users over a two-month period on a major social media platform. Our results suggest a greater capacity for DM to transmit novel information compared to BC, although DM typically involves stronger ties. Furthermore, the "strength of weak ties" is only evident in BC, not in DM where weaker ties do not transmit significantly more novel information. Our mechanism analysis indicates that the content selection by both senders and recipients, contingent on tie strength, contributes to the observed differences between these two channels. These findings expand both our understanding of contemporary weak tie theory and our knowledge of how to disseminate novel information in social networks.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how different virus - spreading channels (i.e., information - spreading patterns) affect the ability of "the strength of weak ties" to transmit novel information in social networks. Specifically, the research focuses on two main virus - spreading channels: direct messages (DM) and broadcasts (BC), and analyzes their impact on transmitting novel information.
### Research Background and Problem Statement
1. **Information Spreading in Social Networks**
- Social media networks have become the main source for individuals to obtain new information. Exposure to new information can stimulate creativity and innovation, and help reduce information inequality, bridge social divides, and encourage active participation in community and social activities.
- However, continuous exposure to homogeneous and redundant information will lead to the fragmentation and polarization of views, exacerbating the knowledge gap and social division.
2. **The Roles of Strong and Weak Ties**
- Granovetter (1973) proposed "the strength of weak ties", emphasizing that weak ties, as bridges between different social circles, play an important role in transmitting novel and valuable information.
- Strong ties tend to be difficult to provide novel information due to their high homogeneity. Weak ties can access a wider range of information sources, thus increasing the novelty of information.
3. **The Role of Virus - Spreading Channels**
- Although a large number of studies have explored the roles of strong and weak ties in information transmission, less attention has been paid to how different virus - spreading channels (such as direct messages and broadcasts) affect this process.
- This study aims to fill this gap and explore the differences between DM and BC, the two main virus - spreading channels, in transmitting novel information through large - scale empirical analysis.
### Research Methods
- **Data Sources**
- The study used data from a large - scale social media platform to track the information - sharing behaviors of 500,000 users within two months.
- **Analysis Dimensions**
- **Marginal Uniqueness**: The probability that the shared information in a given relationship involves unique topics or sources.
- **Marginal Non - Redundancy**: The probability that the shared information in a given relationship introduces topics or sources different from those received by the receiver in history.
- **Marginal Diversity**: The marginal change of information diversity in all social relationships by a relationship, measured by Shannon entropy.
### Main Findings
1. **Information Novelty of DM vs BC**
- The results show that DM transmits significantly more new information than BC, although DM usually involves stronger relationships.
- In DM, weaker relationships do not necessarily transmit more novel information, while in BC, weaker relationships are more effective in transmitting novel information.
2. **Content Selection Mechanisms**
- Senders tend to share more unique and diverse content in DM, especially in interactions with stronger relationships.
- Receivers in DM are more inclined to interact with novel information from stronger relationships, which may be attributed to the trust and common interests of stronger relationships.
3. **Gender Differences**
- Research on male and female receivers shows that DM transmits significantly more new information than BC.
- Female users receive more novel topics in both channels than male users, which may be related to female behavior of exploring new content.
### Conclusion
This study expands the understanding of contemporary weak - tie theory and reveals the important moderating role of virus - spreading channels in information transmission. The research results show that the effective transmission of novel information depends not only on the strength of relationships but also on the influence of transmission channels. These findings provide a new perspective on how to use social relationships and transmission channels to effectively transmit novel information.