Abstract:Analyzing privacy threats in software products is an essential part of software development to ensure systems are privacy-respecting; yet it is still a far from trivial activity. While there have been many advancements in the past decade, they tend to focus on describing 'what' the threats are. What isn't entirely clear yet is 'how' to actually find these threats. Privacy is a complex domain. We propose to use four conceptual layers (feature, ecosystem, business context, and environment) to capture this privacy complexity. These layers can be used as a frame to structure and specify the privacy analysis support in a more tangible and actionable way, thereby improving applicability of the analysis process.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the complexity and lack of specific guidance in the current privacy threat modeling process. Although many advances have been made in the field of privacy threat modeling in the past decade, these advances have mainly focused on describing "what privacy threats are", and the specific methods for actually finding these threats are still not clear and actionable enough.
### Specific problems include:
1. **Insufficient methods for identifying privacy threats**:
- Although there are many frameworks and tools that can help describe privacy threats, in actual operation, the methods for systematically identifying and evaluating these threats are still not perfect. Although the existing methods provide theoretical guidance, they lack specific and actionable steps in practical applications.
2. **Multi - layer complexity of privacy analysis**:
- Privacy issues involve complexity at multiple levels, including Feature, Ecosystem, Business Context, and Environment. Each level has its own unique challenges and influencing factors, and existing methods often fail to fully consider the interactions between these different levels.
3. **The need for interdisciplinary approaches**:
- Privacy threat modeling is not just a technical issue, but also involves multiple aspects such as law, society, and culture. Therefore, an interdisciplinary approach is required to comprehensively understand and address privacy threats. Existing methods are insufficient in integrating these non - technical factors.
### Solutions proposed in the paper:
To address the above problems, the author proposes a privacy threat analysis framework based on a four - layer conceptual model. These four layers are:
- **Feature Layer**: Focus on the core functions of the system and the user journey, and understand the specific behaviors and data flows of the system.
- **Ecosystem Layer**: Consider the interaction between the system and external services and the technological ecosystem, and ensure that all possible data flows and dependencies are understood.
- **Business Context Layer**: Analyze business requirements and values, and understand why a certain function needs to be developed and its impact on stakeholders.
- **Environment Layer**: Consider external environmental factors such as laws and regulations, cultural differences, and social expectations to ensure the comprehensiveness of privacy analysis.
Through this multi - level analysis framework, the author hopes to provide a more structured and specific way to guide the identification and evaluation of privacy threats, thereby improving the practicality and effectiveness of privacy analysis.
### Summary:
This paper aims to solve the problems of complexity and lack of specific guidance in the privacy threat modeling process by introducing a multi - level conceptual model. This framework not only covers the technical level, but also includes considerations in multiple aspects such as business, law, and society, providing a more comprehensive and actionable method for the identification and evaluation of privacy threats.