Competition between Kondo Effect and RKKY Coupling

Stefan Kettemann

2024-08-06

Abstract:When magnetic moments are immersed into the Fermi sea of itinerant electrons, rich quantum physics emerges. This is relevant for a wide range of materials including heavy Fermion systems, high temperature superconductors like the cuprates, but also good metals with magnetic impurities, doped semiconductors like Si:P close to the metal-insulator transition, 2D materials like graphene and topological insulators. While each material has its specific properties, requiring detailed modelling, their electronic properties are to some degree governed by the competition between Kondo screening and indirect exchange couplings. In these lecture notes we give an introduction, starting with a review of formation of magnetic moments, the theory of the Kondo effect for a single magnetic impurity in a metal host and the derivation of RKKY coupling between magnetic impurities in a metal host. We review the Doniach diagram and Kondo lattice physics and give an introduction to a self consistent renormalization group theory, taking into account Kondo effect and RKKY coupling between magnetic impurities and review results obtained thereby. We review the effect of gaps and pseudo gaps on Kondo effect and RKKY couplings, and on their competition. Especially for dilute concentration of magnetic moments, disorder effects from randomly distributed impurities result in a distribution of both Kondo temperatures and RKKY couplings. Then, their competition becomes an even more complex problem. Moreover, disorder induced Anderson localization transitions may occur, affecting both Kondo effect and RKKY coupling severely, and changing their competition. These disorder effects on the spin competition are introduced and recent results are reviewed. We conclude with an outlook and list of, in our view, most pressing and interesting open problems.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper explores the interaction between local magnetic moments and conduction electrons in metals, particularly the competition between the **Kondo effect** and **RKKY coupling**. Specifically:

1. **Kondo Effect**: When a magnetic impurity in a metal (such as an Fe atom in gold) interacts with the spins in the Fermi sea through an exchange coupling J, if the exchange coupling is antiferromagnetic (i.e., J > 0) and not strong enough to completely bind an electron into a singlet state, all conduction electrons will compete to form a singlet with this local spin. This competition leads to significantly enhanced magnetic scattering and normal scattering, which can be measured by an increase in resistivity. As the temperature decreases to the Kondo temperature TK, this scattering peaks, and then the resistivity decreases further with lowering temperature.

2. **RKKY Coupling**: When the concentration of magnetic moments in the metal is higher and forms a regular lattice, Kondo impurities can conspire to form a narrow band below the Fermi level. At this point, conduction electrons near the Fermi level no longer scatter from the potential field of the Kondo impurities but pass through the lattice formed by the Kondo impurities as quasiparticles with significantly increased mass, forming the so-called heavy fermion state. This transition is usually observed experimentally as a sudden drop in resistivity at a critical temperature Tc.

3. **Competition between Kondo Effect and RKKY Coupling**: As the density of magnetic moments increases, the typical strength of RKKY coupling also increases. Therefore, there is a competition between the Kondo effect and RKKY coupling, depending on which mechanism dominates. This competition can be systematically studied by gradually increasing the concentration of magnetic impurities. Ultimately, this competition leads to quantum phase transitions, such as the transition from a heavy fermion state to an ordered state, known as the Doniach diagram.

In summary, the paper focuses on understanding and describing the competitive relationship between the Kondo effect and RKKY coupling, particularly the quantum phase transition behavior of the system at different concentrations of magnetic impurities.