Modeling the impact of Climate transition on real estate prices

Lionel Sopgoui

2024-08-05

Abstract:In this work, we propose a model to quantify the impact of the climate transition on a property in housing market. We begin by noting that property is an asset in an economy. That economy is organized in sectors, driven by its productivity which is a multidimensional Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, while the climate transition is declined thanks to the carbon price, a continuous deterministic process. We then extend the sales comparison approach and the income approach to valuate an energy inefficient real estate asset. We obtain its value as the difference between the price of an equivalent efficient building following an exponential Ornstein-Uhlenbeck as well as the actualized renovation costs and the actualized sum of the future additional energy costs. These costs are due to the inefficiency of the building, before an optimal renovation date which depends on the carbon price process. Finally, we carry out simulations based on the French economy and the house price index of France. Our results allow to conclude that the order of magnitude of the depreciation obtained by our model is the same as the empirical observations.

Risk Management,General Economics,General Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to quantify the impact of climate transition on real estate market prices. Specifically, the author aims to evaluate through modelling how climate transition (especially changes in carbon prices) affects the value of energy - inefficient buildings.

### Main problems and methods

1. **Problem background**:
- Real estate is an important part of the economy, accounting for approximately 10% - 40% of annual investment and 15% - 25% of household disposable income.
- Climate change has had a profound impact on human society and its environment, and transition risks (potential economic losses related to the adjustment to a low - carbon economy) are becoming increasingly important.
- Residential and commercial buildings are one of the main sources of greenhouse gas emissions, especially in the European Union (EU), where approximately 9% of total emissions come from residential heating and cooling.

2. **Research objectives**:
- Propose a model to quantify the impact of climate transition on real estate market prices.
- Calculate the market value of energy - inefficient buildings before and after the optimal renovation date by considering energy costs and renovation costs.

3. **Methods**:
- **Sales comparison method**: Use the transaction prices of highly comparable properties recently sold to determine the market value of a given building.
- **Income method**: Consider the value of a property as the sum of the discounted net rent during its remaining life minus all operating costs.
- Introduce carbon price as a driver of climate transition and assume it to be a continuous deterministic process.
- Use the exponential Ornstein - Uhlenbeck process to simulate the price of efficient buildings and consider the actualized future additional energy costs and renovation costs.

4. **Key formulas**:
- The price of a building can be expressed as:
\[
C_t^\delta = R \cdot \text{ess sup}_{\theta \ge t} E \left[ \int_t^\theta [D_s - (\alpha - \alpha^*) f(\delta_u, p)] e^{-\bar{r}(u - t)} du - c(\alpha, \alpha^*) e^{-\bar{r}(\theta - t)} + \int_\theta^{+\infty} e^{-\bar{r}(s - t)} D_{t + s} ds \mid U_t \right]
\]
where:
- \( c(\alpha, \alpha^*) \) is the renovation cost of improving from energy efficiency \(\alpha\) to \(\alpha^*\).
- \( f(\delta_u, p) \) is the energy price function, which depends on the carbon price \(\delta_u\) and the energy source \(p\).
- \( D_s \) is the income of the building at time \(s\).
- \(\bar{r}\) is the discount rate.

5. **Conclusions**:
- The simulation results of the French economy and housing price index in the paper show that the depreciation magnitude obtained by the model is consistent with empirical observations.

### Summary

By introducing the risks of climate transition, especially changes in carbon prices, this paper proposes a new real estate valuation model. This model not only considers the future energy costs of energy - inefficient buildings but also the choice of the optimal renovation date, thus more accurately reflecting the impact of climate transition on the real estate market.