Proof of off-diagonal long-range order in a mean-field trapped Bose gas via the Feynman--Kac formula

Tianyi Bai,Wolfgang König,Quirin Vogel
2024-08-05
Abstract:We consider the non-interacting Bose gas of $N$ bosons in dimension $d\geq 3$ in a trap in a mean-field setting with a vanishing factor $a_N$ in front of the kinetic energy. The choice $a_N=N^{-2/d}$ is the semi-classical setting and was analysed in great detail in a special, interacting case in Deuchert and Seiringer (2021). Using a version of the well-known Feynman--Kac representation and a further representation in terms of a Poisson point process, we derive precise asymptotics for the reduced one-particle density matrix, implying off-diagonal long-range order (ODLRO, a well-known criterion for Bose--Einstein condensation) for $a_N$ above a certain threshold and non-occurrence of ODLRO for $a_N$ below that threshold. In particular, we relate the condensate and its total mass to the amount of particles in long loops in the Feynman--Kac formula, the order parameter that Feynman suggested in Feynman (1953). For $a_N\ll N^{-2/d}$, we prove that all loops have the minimal length one, and for $a_N\gg N^{-2/d}$ we prove 100 percent condensation and identify the distribution of the long-loop lengths as the Poisson--Dirichlet distribution.
Probability
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to study the condensation phenomenon of non - interacting Bose gases in a specific mean - field setting. Specifically, the main objectives of the paper are as follows: 1. **Derive new physically relevant results**: For a specific version of the mean - field Bose gas, derive new, physically relevant Bose - condensation results. 2. **Rigorously prove the strong relationship between the condensate and long cycles**: Provide rigorous evidence of the relationship between the condensate and long cycles through the well - known Feynman - Kac representation. 3. **Provide new probabilistic proofs**: Use the language and toolbox of probability theory to attract the attention of the probability theory community to this fascinating topic. ### Background and main contributions - **Background**: Since Feynman proposed in 1953 that the number of particles in long cycles may be an important order parameter for describing Bose - Einstein condensation, Bose gases have also become a mathematically interesting research object in the field of probability theory. However, most current probability theory research has not yet had practical physical significance. - **Main contributions**: - This paper focuses on physically relevant problems while establishing and developing the probability theory toolbox. - It studies the condensation phase transition of Bose gases in a specific mean - field setting. - Using the Feynman - Kac representation and the Poisson point process representation, it derives the exact asymptotic behavior of the one - particle reduced density matrix, thereby proving the existence and non - existence of off - diagonal long - range order (ODLRO). - It describes the distribution of the condensate as the total mass of long cycles in the Feynman - Kac formula and determines the limiting distribution of the long - cycle length. ### Specific problems and methods - **Model**: Consider \(N\) non - interacting bosons in \(d\geq3\) dimensions in a mean - field setting in a trap, with a vanishing factor \(a_N\) in front of the kinetic energy. - **Key parameter**: Choose \(a_N = N^{- 2/d}\) for the semi - classical setting. This setting is particularly interesting because it exhibits a condensation phase transition at a fixed positive temperature. - **Methods**: - Use the Feynman - Kac representation and the Poisson point process representation. - Derive the exact asymptotic behavior of the one - particle reduced density matrix. - Prove the existence and non - existence of the condensate by analyzing the distribution of long cycles. ### Main results - **Supercritical case** (\(\chi>\rho_w\)): - The one - particle reduced density matrix behaves as \(\gamma(a_N)_N(x,y)=N\left(1 - \frac{\rho_w}{\chi}\right)\phi_1^{(w/a_N)}(x)\phi_1^{(w/a_N)}(y)(1 + o(1))\) in the weak \(L^2\) sense. - The distribution of the long - cycle length converges to the Poisson - Dirichlet distribution. - The expression for the free energy is \(f_{\text{MF}}(\beta,\chi)=-\frac{p(0)}{\beta\chi}+\lambda_1(W)\left(1 - \frac{\rho_w}{\chi}\right)\lim_{N\rightarrow\infty}a_N\). - **Subcritical case** (\(\chi<\rho_w\)): - The upper bound of the one - particle reduced density matrix is \(\gamma(a_N)_N(x,y)=O\left(a_N^{-d/2}e^{-c|x - y|a_N^{-1/2}}\right)\). - The distribution of the long - cycle length weakly converges to \(\alpha(\chi)\). - The expression for the free energy is \(f_{\text{MF}}(\beta,\chi)=\begin{cases}-\frac{p(u_\chi)}{\beta\chi}+u_\chi, &\text{if }\chi>0,\\-\infty, &\text{if }\chi = 0.\end{cases}\) ### Conclusion - **Off - diagonal long - range order**