Abstract:We consider the use of automated supervised learning systems for data tables that not only contain numeric/categorical columns, but one or more text fields as well. Here we assemble 18 multimodal data tables that each contain some text fields and stem from a real business application. Our publicly-available benchmark enables researchers to comprehensively evaluate their own methods for supervised learning with numeric, categorical, and text features. To ensure that any single modeling strategy which performs well over all 18 datasets will serve as a practical foundation for multimodal text/tabular AutoML, the diverse datasets in our benchmark vary greatly in: sample size, problem types (a mix of classification and regression tasks), number of features (with the number of text columns ranging from 1 to 28 between datasets), as well as how the predictive signal is decomposed between text vs. numeric/categorical features (and predictive interactions thereof). Over this benchmark, we evaluate various straightforward pipelines to model such data, including standard two-stage approaches where NLP is used to featurize the text such that AutoML for tabular data can then be applied. Compared with human data science teams, the fully automated methodology that performed best on our benchmark (stack ensembling a multimodal Transformer with various tree models) also manages to rank 1st place when fit to the raw text/tabular data in two MachineHack prediction competitions and 2nd place (out of 2380 teams) in Kaggle's Mercari Price Suggestion Challenge.

Table Transformers for Imputing Textual Attributes

Not Another Imputation Method: A Transformer-based Model for Missing Values in Tabular Datasets

Table-To-Text generation and pre-training with TabT5

Retrieval-Based Transformer for Table Augmentation

TabText: A Flexible and Contextual Approach to Tabular Data Representation

Tabular Transformers for Modeling Multivariate Time Series

TUTA: Tree-based Transformers for Generally Structured Table Pre-training

TETA: Text-Enhanced Tabular Data Annotation with Multi-task Graph Convolutional Network

Single Cells Are Spatial Tokens: Transformers for Spatial Transcriptomic Data Imputation

XTab: Cross-table Pretraining for Tabular Transformers

TFWT: Tabular Feature Weighting with Transformer

Benchmarking Multimodal AutoML for Tabular Data with Text Fields

A Comparative Study on Imputation Techniques: Introducing a Transformer Model for Robust and Efficient Handling of Missing EEG Amplitude Data

Text-Tuple-Table: Towards Information Integration in Text-to-Table Generation via Global Tuple Extraction

Cross-modal missing time-series imputation using dense spatio-temporal transformer nets

TREB: a BERT attempt for imputing tabular data imputation

TableFormer: Table Structure Understanding with Transformers

Text-to-Table: A New Way of Information Extraction

ImputeFormer: Low Rankness-Induced Transformers for Generalizable Spatiotemporal Imputation

P-Transformer: A Prompt-based Multimodal Transformer Architecture For Medical Tabular Data

MATE: Multi-view Attention for Table Transformer Efficiency