Finite groups with some particular maximal invariant subgroups being nilpotent or all non-nilpotent maximal invariant subgroups being normal

Jiangtao Shi,Fanjie Xu
2024-08-02
Abstract:Let $A$ and $G$ be finite groups such that $A$ acts coprimely on $G$ by automorphisms. We provide a complete classification of a finite group $G$ in which every maximal $A$-invariant subgroup containing the normalizer of some $A$-invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. Moreover, we show that both the hypothesis that every maximal $A$-invariant subgroup of $G$ containing the normalizer of some $A$-invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent and the hypothesis that every non-nilpotent maximal $A$-invariant subgroup of $G$ is normal are equivalent.
Group Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily focuses on the properties of a finite group \(G\) under the action of certain subgroups, particularly when another finite group \(A\) acts on \(G\) via automorphisms in a coprime order manner. The core contribution of the paper lies in classifying the nilpotency of certain maximal invariant subgroups and exploring the relationship between these conditions and the structural properties of the group \(G\). Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues: 1. **Nilpotency of Maximal Invariant Subgroups**: - When every maximal \(A\)-invariant subgroup of \(G\) that contains the normalizer of some \(A\)-invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent, the paper provides the specific structure of the group \(G\). The paper offers a complete classification, stating that \(G\) satisfying the above condition is either nilpotent itself or has a specific decomposition form (Theorem 1.3). 2. **Normality of Non-Nilpotent Maximal Invariant Subgroups**: - The paper explores the equivalence between the condition that all non-nilpotent maximal \(A\)-invariant subgroups are normal in \(G\) and the aforementioned condition. This further reveals how these conditions influence the overall structure of \(G\) (Theorem 1.9). To prove these results, the authors utilize a series of auxiliary lemmas, including properties of the nilpotency and normality of maximal invariant subgroups, properties of Hall subgroups, and more. Ultimately, the paper not only provides new classification results but also extends and refines the work of previous researchers.