Game Theory Based Community-Aware Opinion Dynamics

Shanfan Zhang,Xiaoting Shen,Zhan Bu

2024-08-02

Abstract:Examining the mechanisms underlying the formation and evolution of opinions within real-world social systems, which consist of numerous individuals, can provide valuable insights for effective social functioning and informed business decision making. The focus of our study is on the dynamics of opinions inside a networked multi-agent system. We provide a novel approach called the Game Theory Based Community-Aware Opinion Formation Process (GCAOFP) to accurately represent the co-evolutionary dynamics of communities and opinions in real-world social systems. The GCAOFP algorithm comprises two distinct steps in each iteration. 1) The Community Dynamics Process conceptualizes the process of community formation as a non-cooperative game involving a finite number of agents. Each individual agent aims to maximize their own utility by adopting a response that leads to the most favorable update of the community label. 2) The Opinion Formation Process involves the updating of an individual agent's opinion within a community-aware framework that incorporates bounded confidence. This process takes into account the updated matrix of community members and ensures that an agent's opinion aligns with the opinions of others within their community, within certain defined limits. The present study provides a theoretical proof that under any initial conditions, the aforementioned co-evolutionary dynamics process will ultimately reach an equilibrium state. In this state, both the opinion vector and community member matrix will stabilize after a finite number of iterations. In contrast to conventional opinion dynamics models, the guaranteed convergence of agent opinion within the same community ensures that the convergence of opinions takes place exclusively inside a given community.

Computer Science and Game Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in real - world social systems, how to accurately simulate and understand the co - evolution process between community structure and opinion dynamics. Specifically, the research aims to develop a new method to represent the co - evolution dynamics of communities and opinions in social networks and ensure that this evolution can eventually reach a stable state.

### Detailed Explanation of the Main Problem:

1. **Limitations of Existing Models**:
- Traditional opinion dynamics models usually assume that individuals (agents) only exchange opinions with their direct neighbors, ignoring higher - order connection relationships, such as connections within the community.
- These models fail to fully consider the influence of community structure on opinion formation, resulting in limited effectiveness in practical applications.

2. **Introduction of Community - Aware Mechanisms**:
- The research proposes a game - theory - based Community - Aware Opinion Formation Process (GCAOFP). This model not only considers the update of individual opinions but also the dynamic changes of community structure.
- The GCAOFP model achieves this goal through two stages:
1. **Community Dynamics Process (CDP)**: Model the community formation process as a non - cooperative game. The goal of each individual is to maximize its utility function, thereby choosing the most appropriate community label.
2. **Opinion Formation Process (OFP)**: Update the individual's opinion within the community - aware framework, ensuring that the individual's opinion remains consistent with the opinions of its community members within a certain range.

3. **Theoretical Guarantees and Empirical Verification**:
- It is theoretically proven that under any initial conditions, the GCAOFP model can reach a stable state within a finite number of iterations, that is, the opinion vector and the community member matrix will tend to be stable.
- The effectiveness and scalability of the GCAOFP model are verified through experiments on multiple real - world networks, and compared with existing graph clustering methods, showing its superiority.

### Formula Summary:
- **Utility Function**:
\[
u_i(t)=\lambda_i\sum_{j\neq i}S_i(t)S_j^T(t)\cdot[\psi - |x_i(T)-x_j(T)|]\cdot W_{ij}+\sum_{j\neq i}(1 - S_i(t)S_j^T(t))\cdot\text{ReLU}[\psi - |x_i(T)-x_j(T)|]\cdot W_{ij}
\]

- **Opinion Update Rule**:
\[
x_i(T + 1)=\delta_i(T)x_i(T)+\sum_{j\neq i}\Phi_{ij}(T)\cdot x_j(T)
\]
where,
\[
\Phi_{ij}(T)=\frac{(1+(\lambda_i - 1)S_i(t)S_j^T(t))\omega_{ij}}{\sum_{j\neq i}(1+(\lambda_i - 1)S_i(t)S_j^T(t))\omega_{ij}+1}
\]
\[
\omega_{ij}=W_{ij}\cdot\text{ReLU}[\beta\gamma^T - |x_i(T)-x_j(T)|]
\]

Through these formulas, the GCAOFP model can effectively simulate the co - evolution process of communities and opinions both theoretically and practically.