Does empirical evidence from healthy aging studies predict a practical difference between visualizations for different age groups?

S. Shao,Y. Li,A. I. Meso,N. Holliman

2024-08-03

Abstract:When communicating critical information to decision-makers, one of the major challenges in visualization is whether the communication is affected by different perceptual or cognitive abilities, one major influencing factor is age. We review both visualization and psychophysics literature to understand where quantitative evidence exists on age differences in visual perception. Using contrast sensitivity data from the literature we show how the differences between visualizations for different age groups can be predicted using a new model of visible frequency range with age. The model assumed that at threshold values some visual data will not be visible to older people (spatial frequency > 2 and contrast <=0.01). We apply this result to a practical visualization and show an example that at higher levels of contrast, the visual signal should be perceivable by all viewers over 20. Universally usable visualization should use a contrast of 0.02 or higher and be designed to avoid spatial frequencies greater than eight cycles per degree to accommodate all ages. There remains much research to do on to translate psychophysics results to practical quantitative guidelines for visualization producers.

Graphics,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there are significant differences in the understanding and processing of visual information among people of different age groups due to differences in perceptual and cognitive abilities in data visualization. Specifically, the author focuses on how to predict the differences in the effectiveness of different age groups when using specific visualization methods through existing empirical evidence. The paper pays special attention to the index of contrast sensitivity, explores its trend with age, and attempts to establish a model to predict the visible range of different age groups at different spatial frequencies.

### Core issues of the paper
- **Main research question**: Can the empirical evidence in healthy aging research predict the differences among different age groups when using visualization tools?
- **Specific objectives**:
- Collect and analyze the empirical evidence regarding the relationship between age and contrast sensitivity in the visual psychology literature.
- Establish a model for predicting the visible range of different age groups at different spatial frequencies.
- Apply these research results to actual data visualization design and provide specific guidance suggestions.

### Research background
With the aging of society, more and more elderly people need to use electronic devices for data visualization. However, the visual ability of the elderly declines with age, which may affect their understanding and use of data visualization. Therefore, it is particularly important to study how to design visualization tools suitable for users of all age groups.

### Main findings
- **Contrast sensitivity declines with age**: Research shows that starting from the age of 30, the contrast sensitivity at medium - high spatial frequencies begins to decline, and this downward trend will continue into old age.
- **Model prediction**: By establishing a model based on contrast sensitivity, the visible range of different age groups at different spatial frequencies can be predicted. For example, the model assumes that under threshold conditions (spatial frequency > 2, contrast <= 0.01), some visual data are invisible to the elderly.
- **Practical application**: In order to ensure that users of all age groups can effectively use data visualization tools, it is recommended to use a design with a contrast not lower than 0.02 and avoid using a spatial frequency exceeding 8 cycles per degree.

### Conclusion
Through comprehensive analysis of existing literature and model establishment, the paper provides empirical evidence regarding the differences among different age groups when using data visualization tools. These research results not only help to understand the visual limitations of the elderly when using electronic devices, but also can provide a scientific basis for designing more general and effective data visualization tools.