Abstract:Fredman proposed in 1976 the following algorithmic problem: Given are a ground set $X$, some partial order $P$ over $X$, and some comparison oracle $O_L$ that specifies a linear order $L$ over $X$ that extends $P$. A query to $O_L$ has as input distinct $x, x' \in X$ and outputs whether $x <_L x'$ or vice versa. If we denote by $e(P)$ the number of linear extensions of $P$, then $\log e(P)$ is a worst-case lower bound on the number of queries needed to output the sorted order of $X$. Fredman did not specify in what form the partial order is given. Haeupler, Hladík, Iacono, Rozhon, Tarjan, and Tětek ('24) propose to assume as input a directed acyclic graph, $G$, with $m$ edges and $n=|X|$ vertices. Denote by $P_G$ the partial order induced by $G$. Algorithmic performance is measured in running time and the number of queries used, where they use $\Theta(m + n + \log e(P_G))$ time and $\Theta(\log e(P_G))$ queries to output $X$ in its sorted order. Their algorithm is worst-case optimal in terms of running time and queries, both. Their algorithm combines topological sorting with heapsort. Their analysis relies upon sophisticated counting arguments using entropy, recursively defined sets defined over the run of their algorithm, and vertices in the graph that they identify as bottlenecks for sorting. In this paper, we do away with sophistication. We show that when the input is a directed acyclic graph then the problem admits a simple solution using $\Theta(m + n + \log e(P_G))$ time and $\Theta(\log e(P_G))$ queries. Especially our proofs are much simpler as we avoid the usage of advanced charging arguments and data structures, and instead rely upon two brief observations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the problem of efficiently ordering the vertices of a given Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG). Specifically, the paper focuses on the problem of ordering with partial information, i.e., given a vertex set $ X $ and a partial order $ P $, as well as a comparison oracle $ O_L $ that can access a linear order $ L $, the goal is to minimize the number of queries to $ O_L $ to recover the linear order of $ X $. ### Background and Motivation 1. **Fredman's Problem**: - In 1976, Fredman posed an algorithmic problem: given a vertex set $ X $, a partial order $ P $, and a comparison oracle $ O_L $ that can access a linear order $ L $, how to determine the linear order of $ X $ with the minimum number of queries. - Basic information theory indicates that at least $ \lceil \log_2(e(P)) \rceil $ queries are needed, where $ e(P) $ denotes the number of linear extensions of the partial order $ P $. 2. **Existing Work**: - Several researchers have proposed different algorithms to solve this problem, but these algorithms either have high time complexity or high query complexity. - Haeupler et al. proposed an algorithm that combines topological sorting and heap sorting, which can complete the sorting in $ \Theta(m + n + \log e(P_G)) $ time and uses $ \Theta(\log e(P_G)) $ queries, where $ P_G $ is the partial order induced by the graph $ G $. ### Main Contributions of the Paper 1. **Simplified Algorithm**: - This paper proposes a simpler algorithm that can accomplish the sorting task with the same time and query complexity. - The algorithm first extracts the longest directed path $ \pi $ from the graph $ G $, then iteratively removes any source node $ x_i $ from the remaining graph $ H $ and inserts it into the path $ \pi $. 2. **Algorithm Description**: - A dynamic list structure $ T_\pi $ is used to maintain the path $ \pi $, supporting fast insertion and search operations. - For each source node $ x_i $, find its appropriate position in the path $ \pi $ using finger search to determine the insertion position. 3. **Proof of Correctness and Optimality**: - Through combinatorial arguments and geometric observations, the correctness and optimality of the algorithm are proven. - It is proven that the algorithm has a time complexity of $ \Theta(n + m + \log e(P_G)) $ and a query complexity of $ \Theta(\log e(P_G)) $. ### Conclusion This paper addresses the problem of minimizing the number of queries to recover the linear order in a given Directed Acyclic Graph by proposing a simpler and more efficient algorithm. Compared to existing complex algorithms, the proposed algorithm not only maintains optimal time and query complexity but also has a more straightforward proof process.

Simpler Optimal Sorting from a Directed Acyclic Graph

Fast and Simple Sorting Using Partial Information

Stochastic and Worst-Case Generalized Sorting Revisited

Algorithms for the Generalized Poset Sorting Problem

Tight Bounds for Sorting Under Partial Information

Guidesort: Simpler Optimal Deterministic Sorting for the Parallel Disk Model

Universal Optimality of Dijkstra via Beyond-Worst-Case Heaps

Sorting and Selection in Posets

The Geometry of Tree-Based Sorting

Parameterized Complexity of Efficient Sortation

Fast Combinatorial Algorithms for Efficient Sortation

On Instance-Optimal Algorithms for a Generalization of Nuts and Bolts and Generalized Sorting

Topological Sorts on DAGs

A Simplified Derivation of Timing Complexity Lower Bounds for Sorting by Comparisons

Bidirectional Dijkstra's Algorithm is Instance-Optimal

ExpoSort: Breaking the quasi-polynomial-time barrier for reluctant sorting

Faster Approximation Algorithms for Restricted Shortest Paths in Directed Graphs

Single-Source Bottleneck Path Algorithm Faster Than Sorting for Sparse Graphs

k-Pareto Optimality-Based Sorting with Maximization of Choice