Comparing a gauge-invariant formulation and a "conventional complete gauge-fixing approach" for $l=0,1$ mode perturbations on the Schwarzschild background spacetime

Kouji Nakamura
2024-07-31
Abstract:Comparison of the gauge-invariant formulation for $l=0,1$-mode perturbations on the Schwarzschild background spacetime proposed in [K.~Nakamura, Class. Quantum Grav. {\bf 38} (2021), 145010.] and a ``conventional complete gauge-fixing approach'' in which we use the spherical harmonic functions $Y_{lm}$ as the scalar harmonics from the starting point is discussed. Although it is often said that ``gauge-invariant formulations in general-relativistic perturbations are equivalent to complete gauge-fixing approaches,'' as the result of this comparison, we conclude that the derived solutions through the proposed gauge-invariant formulation and those through a ``conventional complete gauge-fixing approach'' are different. It is pointed out that there is a case where the boundary conditions and initial conditions are restricted in a conventional complete gauge-fixing approach.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to compare two methods for dealing with perturbations in the \(l = 0,1\) modes in the Schwarzschild background spacetime: one is the proposed gauge - invariant method, and the other is the traditional fully gauge - fixed method. The paper points out that although it is generally believed that the gauge - invariant formula in general relativity is equivalent to the fully gauge - fixed method, by comparing these two methods, the author finds that the solutions they obtain are not the same. Specifically, in the traditional fully gauge - fixed method of decomposing metric perturbations from the very beginning using spherical harmonic functions \(Y_{lm}\), the boundary conditions and initial conditions may be restricted. Therefore, the paper aims to explore the differences between these two methods and evaluate their effectiveness and applicability in dealing with \(l = 0,1\) mode perturbations. The main contribution of the paper lies in clarifying the differences between the gauge - invariant method and the traditional gauge - fixed method, which is of great significance for understanding the physical meaning of these perturbations and how to choose the appropriate method in practical applications. In addition, the paper also emphasizes that when dealing with these low - order mode perturbations, the gauge - invariant method can provide more extensive and flexible solutions.