Pure shape dynamics, self-subsisting structures, and the nature of time

Antonio Vassallo,Pedro Naranjo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10838-024-09690-9
2024-07-31
Abstract:The paper discusses the possible implications of the relational framework of Pure Shape Dynamics for the metaphysics of time. The starting point of the analysis is an interpretation of shapes in ontic structural realist terms, which gives rise to the notion of self-subsisting structure. The relational version of a Newtonian-particle toy model is introduced and discussed as a concrete example.
History and Philosophy of Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the possible influence of the Pure Shape Dynamics (PSD) framework on the philosophy of time. Specifically, from a relationalist perspective, that is, believing that the only objective spatial information of a physical system is encoded in its shape, and the time structure must be defined only through the changes in the relational configuration of the physical system, the author reconstructs the concept of time. The core objective of the paper is to show how to achieve a robust reconstruction of the concept of time starting from the basic metaphysics that only acknowledges the spatial relations among material bodies and their changes. This includes explaining how to achieve the "emergence" of the arrow of time through the intrinsic geometric properties of material motion, especially by introducing a parameter κ that measures the dynamic degree of deviation of a curve from a geodesic. In addition, by analyzing a specific three - body system model, the paper also shows how to propose a materialist metaphysics of time from this technical framework to refute the above - mentioned skeptical views.