Convection in the active layer speeds up permafrost thaw in coarse grained soils

Marta Magnani,Stefano Musacchio,Antonello Provenzale,Guido Boffetta

2024-07-30

Abstract:Permafrost thaw is a major concern raised by the ongoing climate change. An understudied phenomenon possibly affecting the pace of permafrost thaw is the onset of convective motions within the active layer caused by the density anomaly of water. Here, we explore the effects of groundwater convection on permafrost thawing using a model that accounts for ice - water phase transitions, coupled with the dynamics of the temperature field transported by the Darcy's flow across a porous matrix. Numerical simulations of this model show that ice thawing in the presence of convection is much faster than in the diffusive case and deepens at a constant velocity proportional to the soil permeability. A scaling argument is able to predict correctly the asymptotic velocity. Since in the convective regime the heat transport is mediated by the coherent motion of thermal plumes across the thawed layer, we find that the depth of the thawing interface becomes highly heterogeneous.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how convection accelerates the thawing process of permafrost in the active layer within coarse-grained soils. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Background**: With global climate warming, the thawing of permafrost has become a significant environmental and social issue. The thawing of permafrost not only affects soil stability and health risks but also releases compounds previously frozen in the soil.

2. **Research Focus**: Previous studies have mostly focused on the impact of vertical conductive heat transfer on permafrost thawing. This paper, however, specifically examines the effect of convective movements, triggered by the anomalous density of water, on the thawing rate of permafrost in highly permeable soils (such as gravel).

3. **Model and Simulation**: By constructing a mathematical model that includes ice-water phase change, temperature field dynamics, and Darcy flow in porous media, numerical simulations were conducted. The results show that in the presence of convection, the thawing rate of ice is much faster than in the case of diffusion alone, and the thawing interface deepens at a constant rate proportional to the soil permeability.

4. **Findings and Conclusions**:
- Convection significantly accelerates the thawing process of permafrost.
- In convection-dominated scenarios, the efficiency of heat transfer is higher, leading to a linear growth of the thawing interface over time.
- A highly uneven thawing interface is formed, which can serve as a diagnostic marker for the presence of convection in the active layer.

These results indicate that considering convection processes in climate models is crucial for accurately assessing the thawing depth of permafrost in highly permeable soils. Additionally, the study points out that fire events may promote convection by increasing soil permeability, thereby exacerbating post-fire permafrost degradation.