Prospects of using closure traces directly for imaging in Very Long Baseline Interferometry

Hendrik Müller
2024-07-30
Abstract:The reconstruction of the polarization of a source in radio interferometry is a challenging calibration problem since the reconstruction strongly depends on the gains and leakages that need to be inferred along with the image. This is particularly true for the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) due to its small number of antennas, small signal-to-noise ratio and large gain corruptions. To recover linear polarization, one either has to infer the leakages and gains together with the image structure, or rely completely on calibration independent closure quantities. While the first approach has been explored in Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) for a long time, the later one has been less studied for polarimetry. Closure traces are a recently proposed concept of closure quantities that, in contrast to closure phases and closure amplitudes, are independent against both gains and leakages and carry the relevant information about the polarization of the source. Here we explore, how closure traces could be directly fitted to create an image and point out an imaging pipeline that succeeds in the direct imaging from closure traces. Since closure traces have a number of inherent degeneracies, multiple local image modes that can fit the data are detected. Therefore, a multiobjective imaging technique is needed to correctly sample this multimodality. Closure traces are not constraining enough for the EHT configuration in 2017 to recover an image directly, mainly due to the small number of antennas. For planned successors of the EHT however (with a significantly larger number of antennas), this option becomes feasible and performs competitive to the imaging with residual leakages.
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the possibilities and challenges of directly using closure traces for imaging in Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI). ### Research Background - **VLBI Imaging Challenges**: In VLBI observations, reconstructing the polarization of radio sources is a challenging calibration problem because image reconstruction heavily depends on the gains and leakages that need to be inferred. This issue is particularly pronounced for the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) due to its small number of antennas, low signal-to-noise ratio, and significant gain errors. - **Traditional Use of Closure Quantities**: Traditional VLBI imaging typically employs closure phase and closure amplitude, which are independent of gains and leakages but do not contain absolute position information and total flux information. - **Concept of Closure Traces**: Closure traces are a recently proposed concept of closure quantities. Unlike closure phase and closure amplitude, closure traces are not only independent of gains and leakages but also contain important information about the source polarization. ### Research Objectives - **Imaging Directly from Closure Traces**: Explore how to construct images directly from closure traces and propose an imaging process that can successfully image directly from closure traces. - **Addressing Multimodal Issues**: Due to the inherent multiplicity of closure traces, multiple local image modes that fit the data can be detected. Therefore, a multi-objective imaging technique is needed to correctly sample this multimodality. - **Feasibility Assessment**: Evaluate whether using only closure traces is sufficiently constraining to recover images for the current EHT configuration. For the planned EHT follow-up projects (with significantly more antennas), this approach becomes feasible and performs better than imaging methods with residual leakage. ### Main Findings - **Multimodality Issue**: Due to the multiplicity of closure traces, multiple local image modes fitting the data were detected, necessitating multi-objective imaging techniques to handle this situation correctly. - **Conclusion**: For the current EHT configuration, using only closure traces to directly recover images is not sufficiently constraining, mainly due to the small number of antennas. However, for the planned EHT follow-up projects (with significantly more antennas), this method becomes feasible and performs comparably to imaging methods with residual leakage. In summary, this paper provides new perspectives and technical pathways for future radio interferometric imaging by studying the direct application of closure traces in VLBI.