"How lonely are you?" The role of social contacts and farm characteristics in farmers' self-reported feelings of loneliness, and why it matters

Victoria Junquera,Daniel I. Rubenstein,Florian Knaus

2024-07-30

Abstract:Loneliness and social isolation among farmers are growing public health concerns. The contributing factors are manifold, and some of them are linked to structural change in agriculture, for instance because of higher workloads, rural depopulation, or reduced opportunities for collaboration. Our work explores the interconnections between loneliness, social contacts, and structural factors in agriculture based on a survey of 110 farm managers in the mountain region of Entlebuch, Switzerland combined with agricultural census data. We use path analysis, in which loneliness is the main outcome, and social contacts are an explanatory and explained variable. We find that 3% of respondents report that they feel lonely frequently or very frequently, and the rest sometimes (20%), rarely (40%) or never (38%). Managers with higher workloads report feeling lonely more frequently, and this relationship is direct, as well as indirect because of less frequent social contacts. However, physical isolation is not a significant predictor of loneliness. Moreover, short food supply chains correlate with less frequent loneliness feelings. Our study sheds light on the effects that structural change can have on the social fabric of rural areas.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between farmers' self-reported loneliness and their social connections and farm characteristics, and analyzes how these factors influence farmers' loneliness. The core issue of the study is the prevalent loneliness and social isolation among the farming community, which have become increasingly prominent public health concerns.

The research background indicates that mental health issues among farmers are becoming more severe, including higher suicide rates. The unique nature of agricultural work may lead to physical and emotional stress, with high work intensity combined with uncontrollable external stressors (such as disease outbreaks, weather changes, etc.) potentially resulting in high stress and mental health problems. Additionally, changes in agricultural structure may exacerbate these issues, such as farm expansion, reduction in the number of farms, and the gradual replacement of family labor with hired labor.

The study surveyed 110 farm managers in the Entlebuch region of Switzerland, combined with agricultural census data, and used path analysis methods to explore the relationships between loneliness, social connections, and agricultural structural factors. The study found that 3% of respondents reported feeling lonely often or very frequently, while the rest reported feeling lonely sometimes (20%), rarely (40%), or never (38%). Managers with higher workloads reported feeling lonely more frequently, with both direct and indirect reasons for this association, namely fewer social interaction opportunities. However, physical isolation was not a significant predictor of loneliness. Additionally, shorter food supply chains were associated with less loneliness.

In summary, the paper attempts to address the issue of exploring the interaction between farmers' loneliness, their social connections, and changes in agricultural structure, and analyzes how these factors collectively influence farmers' mental health.