Abstract:The non-Hermitian skin effect (NHSE), an anomalous localization behavior of the bulk states, is an inherently non-Hermitian phenomenon, which can not find a counterpart in Hermitian systems. However, the fragility of NHSE has been revealed recently, such as the boundary sensitivity, and it stimulates a lot of studies on discussing the fate of that. Here we present a theorem which shows that the combined spatial reflection symmetry can be considered as a criterion in one-dimensional non-Hermitian systems to determine whether the NHSE can exist or not. Distinct from previous studies, our proposed criterion only relies on analyzing the symmetry of the system, freeing out other requirements, such as the information of the energy spectrum. Furthermore, by taking the non-Hermitian Kitaev chain as an example, we verify our theorem through both a mathematical proof via the non-Bloch band theory and the exact diagonalization numerical studies. Our results reveal a profound connection between the symmetry and the fate of NHSE.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the existence conditions of the non - Hermitian skin effect (NHSE) in non - Hermitian systems. Specifically, the author proposes a symmetry - based method to determine whether the non - Hermitian skin effect (NHSE) will occur in one - dimensional non - Hermitian lattice systems. The main contribution of the paper is to provide a theoretical criterion, that is, the combined - \( P \) symmetry, which can be used as an important standard for judging the existence of NHSE. This method only depends on the symmetry analysis of the system and does not need to consider other information such as the energy spectrum, thus simplifying the process of judging the existence of NHSE.
### Main research content
1. **Problem background**:
- The non - Hermitian skin effect (NHSE) is a phenomenon unique to non - Hermitian systems, manifested as the abnormal localization of bulk states under open - boundary conditions.
- The fragility of NHSE has been revealed, such as its sensitivity to boundaries, which has inspired a large number of studies on its fate.
2. **Proposed method**:
- The author proposes a theorem, pointing out that the combined - \( P \) symmetry can be used as a criterion for judging the existence of NHSE.
- This criterion only depends on the symmetry analysis of the system and does not require other information, such as the energy spectrum.
3. **Verification method**:
- Through mathematical proof and numerical simulation, the author uses the non - Bloch band theory and the exact diagonalization method to verify this theorem.
- Taking the one - dimensional non - Hermitian Kitaev chain as an example, it shows how the combined - space - reflection symmetry determines the fate of NHSE.
### Theorem and its proof
**Theorem**:
For a one - dimensional non - Hermitian lattice system described by the Hamiltonian \( H \), if there exists a combined - space - reflection symmetry \( S\equiv PX \), where \( X \) is a non - spatial symmetry, and the following conditions are satisfied:
1. \( [H, S]=0 \)
2. The relationship of the bulk state under the \( S \) transformation is \( S|\psi\rangle = \sum_{j,i}(\beta_j)^i|\phi'_j\rangle\otimes|-i\rangle \)
Then it can be concluded that if the \( S \) symmetry exists in the system, NHSE will disappear; otherwise, NHSE will exist.
**Proof**:
1. Assume that there exists a bulk state \( |\Psi_1\rangle \) satisfying \( H|\Psi_1\rangle = E|\Psi_1\rangle \).
2. Since \( [H, S]=0 \), we can get \( HS^{-1}|\Psi_1\rangle = ES^{-1}|\Psi_1\rangle \).
3. Therefore, \( |\Psi_2\rangle\equiv S^{-1}|\Psi_1\rangle \) is also a bulk state with the same eigen - energy \( E \).
4. According to the non - Bloch band theory, bulk states with the same eigen - energy have the same non - Bloch complex wave vector \( \beta \) in the same generalized Brillouin zone (GBZ).
5. If \( |\beta| = 1 \), the bulk state is non - localized and there is no skin effect; if \( |\beta|\neq1 \), the bulk state will be localized at one end of the one - dimensional chain.
6. Assume that the skin effect exists and \( |\Psi_1\rangle \) is localized at one end. According to condition (ii), \( |\Psi_2\rangle \) should be localized at the other end, which contradicts the result of the non - Bloch band theory.
7. Therefore, if the \( S \) symmetry exists in the system, NHSE will disappear; otherwise, NHSE will exist.
### Example verification
The author takes the one - dimensional non - Hermitian Kitaev chain as an example to verify the above theorem. Through numerical simulation and non - Bloch band theory, it shows how the combined - space - reflection symmetry determines the existence of NHSE.