The influence of Automated Decision-Making systems in the context of street-level bureaucrats' practices

Manuel Portela,A. Paula Rodriguez Müller,Luca Tangi

2024-07-28

Abstract:In an era of digital governance, the use of automation for individual and cooperative work is increasing in public administrations (Tangi et al., 2022). Despite the promises of efficiency and cost reduction, automation could bring new challenges to the governance schemes. Regional, national, and local governments are taking measures to regulate and measure the impact of automated decision-making systems (ADMS). This research focuses on the use and adoption of ADMS in European public administrations to understand how these systems have been transforming the roles, tasks, and duties of street-level bureaucrats. We conducted a qualitative study in which we interviewed street-level bureaucrats from three administrations who had used an ADMS for several years, which was embedded in their daily work routines. The outcome of our research is an analysis of five dimensions of how collaborative work, the organizational settings, the capacities of bureaucrats and the implementation of the ADMS enable or limit the capacities for offering better services towards the citizens.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the application, impact, and changes in the working methods of frontline civil servants brought about by Automated Decision-Making systems (ADMS) in the field of public administration. The study aims to understand how these systems are adopted and how they affect the roles, tasks, and responsibilities of frontline civil servants.

Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Background and Objectives**:
- In the context of the digital governance era, ADMS show potential in improving efficiency and reducing costs, but they also bring a series of challenges.
- Various regions, countries, and local governments in Europe are taking measures to regulate and assess the impact of ADMS.
- The study uses qualitative analysis methods, interviewing frontline civil servants from three different public administration departments who have been using ADMS as part of their daily work for a long time.
- The goal is to analyze how ADMS affect collaborative work, organizational settings, civil servants' capabilities, and their implementation to better serve citizens.

2. **Scope of the Study**:
- Defines ADMS as an algorithm-based system that can provide a certain degree of automated processing for specific tasks to improve the efficiency or accuracy of the decision-making process.
- Considering regulatory frameworks such as GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation), the study focuses on the application of ADMS in public administration.

3. **Research Questions**:
- The first research question concerns the skills and capabilities required by frontline civil servants to support ADMS.
- The second research question concerns the different types of technological, social, and organizational arrangements that facilitate or hinder the use, implementation, and operation of ADMS in public administration departments.

4. **Expected Outcomes**:
- Construct narratives of user perceptions of ADMS.
- Classify different approaches to algorithmic systems and their pros and cons.
- Identify the outcomes of using ADMS in public administration departments and distill best practices.

5. **Methodology**:
- Adopts the theoretical framework of infrastructure studies, combined with interdisciplinary research methods from information systems.
- Uses participatory design methods, particularly the concept of "artifact ecology," to explore the relationships between artifacts in people's personal lives.
- Collects qualitative data through interviews, ethnographic observations, and document analysis.

6. **Case Studies**:
- Studies three European cases (the VioGen system in Spain, the NAV algorithm in Norway, and the SlimmeCheck system in the Netherlands), which have been using ADMS for at least 2 years.
- Through the study of these cases, analyzes the application effects and challenges of ADMS in different environments.

In summary, this paper aims to deeply explore the practical application effects of ADMS in the field of public administration and how they change the workflows and technical support of civil servants. Through this research, the authors hope to provide valuable insights and recommendations for the future application of ADMS in the public sector.